Skip to main content
CPAG Welfare Rights Home

User account menu

  • Log in

Utility menu - Welfare Rights

  • CPAG Home
  • Benefit rates
  • Shop
  • Training & events

Main navigation

  • Support for advisers
    • Advice line for advisers
    • Support for advisers in England and Wales
    • Support for advisers in Scotland
    • Tell us about your case
  • Handbooks
    • Online handbooks
    • Print handbooks
  • Key topics
    • PIP appeals
    • Maximising income
    • Universal credit
    • Migration to universal credit
    • Survivors of domestic abuse
    • Benefits for migrants
    • Debt
    • Housing costs
    • Personal independence payment
    • Sanctions and work-related requirements
    • Work capability assessment
  • Tools & templates
    • About our tools and templates
    • Universal credit
    • Migration to universal credit
    • Benefits for migrants
    • Personal independence payment
    • Work capability assessment
    • Revision, supersession and appeal procedure
    • Judicial review
    • All tools and templates
  • Benefits in Scotland
    • Scottish benefits
    • More information about benefits in Scotland
    • Other CPAG resources on benefits in Scotland
  • Bulletins & articles
    • Welfare Rights Bulletin
    • Articles
    • eBulletins
  • Test cases
    • About legal test cases
    • Support with an Upper Tribunal case
    • Test case updates
    • Refer a test case
    • Support with the judicial review process
Menu
Search

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Welfare rights
  3. Test cases and legal challenges
  4. Legal test cases

Widowed Parent's Allowance where there has been a religious ceremony

AR v SSWP [2020] UKUT 165 (AAC)
This case concerned entitlement to widowed parent’s allowance (WPA) where the appellant and her partner had undergone a religious ceremony some years prior to his death and considered themselves to be, and held themselves out as being, legally married but were not in fact married under English law. The First-tier Tribunal found that the appellant had no entitlement to WPA as she did not meet the marriage requirement, and permission to appeal to the Upper Tribunal was refused, first by the FtT and then, on renewal, by the UT itself. Following a successful Cart style judicial review of the decision not to allow permission to appeal, the case was remitted to the UT for a decision on the WPA entitlement. The case was heard in the UT before a three judge panel on 13/02/20 and, on 26/05/20, the UT dismissed the appeal.

Read the judgment here

  • Background
  • Legal issues
  • Advising unmarried WPA claimants

Background

The appellant in this case became engaged to her husband in 2007. They planned to have an Islamic marriage ceremony called a Nikah. The appellant checked with her local registry office and her Imam and it was confirmed that the Nikah ceremony would be legally recognized in the UK, with no need for further registration. Following the ceremony in 2010, the appellant used the Nikah certificate to change her surname at work, with the DVLA and with her utility providers.

In 2016, the appellant’s partner died and she claimed bereavement payment and WPA for herself and the couple’s two children. Both benefit claims were refused on the grounds that the appellant and her late partner were not legally married in accordance with the Marriage Act 1949, despite the assurances given to her at the time of her marriage. Under the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992, bereavement payment and WPA can only be paid to a surviving spouse or civil partner and the appellant did not meet this requirement.

The appellant appealed to the FtT and the DWP’s decision was upheld. The FtT refused permission to appeal to the Upper Tribunal and the appellant applied direct to the Upper Tribunal for permission to appeal on the basis that she was being discriminated against on the grounds of marital status. Permission to appeal was refused.

Judicial review proceedings were then commenced in August 2017 challenging the UT’s refusal to grant permission to appeal. The judicial review claim was initially stayed behind Re McLaughlin’s Application, [2018] UKSC 48, a challenge to the marriage requirement for WPA as discriminating against unmarried partners and their children. Permission to apply for judicial review was granted following the successful challenge in McLaughlin. The JR application was ultimately allowed without a hearing and the matter was remitted to the UT, which then granted permission to appeal.

Legal issues

The reason for continuing with the case, despite the success of McLaughlin, is because in McLaughlin all the Supreme Court could do was to issue a declaration of incompatibility that the marriage requirement to qualify for WPA, as set out in primary legislation, was incompatible with the Human Rights Act (HRA). In the present case, we asked the UT to consider whether, in a case where a couple have undergone a marriage ceremony, even one that does not result in a legally recognised marriage, then the requirement under s3 HRA to interpret legislation as far as possible in a way that ensures compliance with the HRA means that ‘spouse’ in s39A SSCBA 1992 should be read as including this sub-group of cohabiting couples.

Commenting on the McLaughlin judgment, the UT noted that a declaration of incompatibility does not affect the validity or continuing operation of the legislative provision in respect of which it is given. The appellant was therefore still required to be the spouse or civil partner of the deceased in order to claim WPA.

The UT held that they were not able to interpret "spouse" to include a person in the appellant's position as to do so would be to go against the “grain” of the legislation. The UT stated:

“In the field of social security law, it is a matter for Parliament to decide who receives benefits and who does not. This Tribunal will ensure the fair and proper allocation of benefits within the law but will not grant socio-economic benefits that Parliament has decided to withhold”.

In the case of WPA, the UT concluded that the grain of the legislation is that only a spouse or civil partner should receive the benefit and that it could not interpret the legislation in the way submitted by the claimant without “crossing the divide between the interpretative function of the courts and matters of policy that are democratically entrusted to Parliament”.

Advising unmarried WPA claimants

While a person that is newly bereaved should claim bereavement support payment (BSP), a new claim for WPA can still be made in respect of deaths that occurred before 06/04/17. A remedial order was issued on 9th February 2023 that extends eligibility for WPA to cohabiting partners with children. See our page on bereavement support payment for unmarried parents (Jackson & Others v SSWP [2020] EWHC 1830) for more information on this.

Test case
Published on
25 June 2022
Relevant to
all of the UK
Status
Concluded

    Advice for advisers

    Free, expert advice on benefit and tax credit issues if you’re a frontline adviser or support worker.

    Contact the advice line.

    • [email protected]
    • [email protected]

    WR Footer

    • Become a subscriber
    • Advice line for advisers
    • Training and events
    • eLearning
    • CPAG shop

    CPAG's Advice and Rights Team

    • Follow us on Twitter

    © 2025 CPAG | Child Poverty Action Group is a charity registered in England and Wales (registration number 294841) and in Scotland (registration number SC039339)

    Company limited by guarantee registered in England (registration number 1993854)

    Housekeeping (footer)

    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy policy
    • Cookies
    • Terms and conditions
    • Feedback and complaints
    Site built by Agile Collective
    End Child Poverty Fundraising Regulator badge with validation link
    • Child poverty in the UK
      • Poverty: facts and figures
      • What is poverty?
      • Causes of poverty
      • Effects of poverty
      • Ending child poverty
    • What we do
      • Our impact
      • Our objectives
      • Our campaigns
        • Imagine
        • End child poverty
        • End child poverty in Scotland
        • Scottish Campaign on Rights to Social Security
        • Past campaigns
      • Project work
        • Cost of the School Day
          • Resources for tackling poverty in schools
            • All Cost of the School Day resources
              • Talking about costs and money at school - advice from parents and carers
              • Create poverty aware school communities
              • Show leadership and take action
              • Communicate about costs and money
              • Offer confidential and supportive conversations
            • Toolkits
            • Calendar
            • eLearning
            • Ideas Bank
              • Awareness, values and ethos
                • Understanding poverty in your area
                • Cost of the School Day Information Booklet for Families
                • Nurturing approaches
                • Rebranding support to boost uptake
              • Entitlements and financial support
                • Boosting free school meal uptake
                • Family support staff
                • Offering support and referrals
                • Promoting support
              • School uniform
                • Simple, affordable and inclusive uniform policies
                • School and cluster run uniform banks
                • Providing new uniform and clothing
                • Parent-led uniform stall
              • Eating at school
                • Breakfast clubs
                • Breakfast, breaktimes and lunch
                • Boosting free school meal uptake
              • Consulting and planning
                • Listening to families
                • Parents leading consultation
                • Children consulting their school community
                • Whole school approaches
                • Creating a Cost of the School Day policy with learners
                • Cost of the School Day calendar, created by learners
              • Events, celebrations and fundraising
                • Pre-loved prom initiative
                • Supporting attendance and easing pressure
                • World Book Week in Dundee
                • Stress-free Halloween celebrations at school
                • Non-stigmatising online fundraising
              • Learners in the lead
                • Cost of the School Day pupil groups
                • Pupils asking parents and carers about costs
                • Young people sharing their views about uniform at the Scottish Parliament
                • Learners take universal free school meal call to the Scottish Parliament
                • Talking directly to politicians about cost barriers at school
                • Cost of the School Day pupil group interview their Headteacher
              • Communicating with families
                • Building relationships and keeping in touch
                • Open and clear written communication about support
                • Communicating commitment to equity
                • Letting everyone know
                • Engaging with partners in the community to share information with families
                • Improved attendance through support and communication
              • Trips, clubs and experiences
                • Funding trips
                • Offering support for trips
              • Learning and resources
                • Digital devices, connectivity and curriculum costs
                • Preparation station
                • After school study cafes
              • Local authority approaches
                • Equity in South Lanarkshire
                • Kit for all, Dundee
                • Financial inclusion support officers in Glasgow
                • Dundee City Council's Cost of the School Day
                • Involving young people in financial inclusion in East Ayrshire schools
              • Parental involvement
                • Parents in partnership
                • Parent equality groups
                • Working with parent groups on costs
            • Big Question report and film
          • Voice network and Youth Voice
            • Voice network in Scotland
            • Voice network news and opportunities - Scotland
            • Voice network activities - Scotland
              • Voice network activities - raising awareness
              • Voice network activities - asking everyone about costs
              • Voice network activities - taking action
            • Youth Voice in Wales
            • Youth Voice in England
          • Contact the Cost of the School Day team
          • The Cost of the School Day reports, blogs and briefings
        • Early Warning System
          • About the Early Warning System
          • Contact the Early Warning System team
          • Early Warning System findings
        • Managed migration
        • Projects in England and Wales
          • Cost of the School Day
          • Early Warning System
          • Secure Futures for Children and Families
          • Managed migration
          • Universal credit, digitalisation and the rule of law
          • Your Work Your Way
        • Projects in Scotland
          • Strengthening Social Security: research into the five family payments
      • CPAG in Scotland
      • The CPAG team
        • CPAG staff
        • CPAG trustees
        • CPAG's patron and ambassadors
        • CPAG trainers
    • Policy and research
      • Findings from our projects
        • The Cost of a Child reports
        • Cost of the School Day reports, blogs and briefings
        • Early Warning System findings
        • Managed migration research project findings
        • Your Work Your Way - findings from the project
        • Secure Futures for Children and Families
        • Universal credit, digitalisation and the rule of law
      • Our position
        • The two-child limit: our position
        • The benefit cap: our position
      • Policy briefings and reports
        • David Webster briefings on benefit sanctions
      • CPAG's Poverty journal
      • Policy books from CPAG
    • Welfare rights
      • Support for advisers
        • Advice line for advisers
        • Support for advisers in England and Wales
          • Support with the judicial review process
            • What judicial review is and how it can help
            • Judicial review template letters
              • Guide to using CPAG's judicial review pre-action letter templates
              • Universal credit and migration to universal credit
              • Other benefits and payments
              • Benefits for people in particular circumstances
              • Decisions, delays and challenging decisions
            • Pursuing to court and finding a solicitor
          • Support with an Upper Tribunal case
        • Support for advisers in Scotland
          • Advising low-income families in Scotland
          • Advising disabled people and carers in Scotland
          • Advising migrant groups in Scotland
          • Advising students in Scotland
          • Advising kinship carers in Scotland
          • Advising care-experienced young people in Scotland
          • Advising families with a child in the care system in Scotland
        • Tell us about your case
      • Handbooks
        • Online handbooks
        • Print handbooks
      • Key topics
        • PIP appeals
          • Introduction
          • Before you appeal
          • Submitting your appeal
          • Checking the law, facts and evidence
          • Writing the submission for your appeal
          • Your appeal hearing
          • What to do when you get the tribunal's decision
        • Maximising income
        • Universal credit
          • Universal credit - the basics
          • Universal credit and sanctions
        • Migration to universal credit
        • Survivors of domestic abuse
          • Financial help for families fleeing domestic abuse
          • Unwanted payments of abuser’s benefit into your account
          • Exceptions to the two-child limit
          • Work-related requirements if you have recently experienced domestic abuse
          • Separated but living in the same property
          • Value of property and its effect on means-tested benefits
        • Benefits for migrants
        • Debt
        • Housing costs
        • Personal independence payment
        • Sanctions and work-related requirements
        • Work capability assessment
      • Tools & templates
        • About our tools and templates
        • Universal credit
        • Migration to universal credit
        • Benefits for migrants
        • Personal independence payment
        • Work capability assessment
        • Revision, supersession and appeal procedure
        • Judicial review
        • All tools and templates
      • Benefits in Scotland
        • Scottish benefits
          • Children and young people
            • Pregnancy and baby payment
            • Early learning payment
            • School age payment
            • Best start foods
            • Scottish child payment
            • Residence rules for best start grant
            • Getting a best start grant if you are not getting a qualifying benefit
            • How to challenge a Social Security Scotland decision
          • Disability benefits
            • Child disability payment
            • Supporting information for child disability payment claims: suggestions for education staff
            • Child winter heating payment
            • Adult disability payment
            • Adult disability payment assessment
            • Scottish adult disability living allowance
            • Pension age disability payment
            • How to challenge a disability benefit decision
          • Help with council tax
            • Council tax reduction
            • Council tax reduction if you live with an adult who is not your partner
            • Council tax reduction if you live in a band E to H property
            • Calculating the new Scottish council tax reduction
            • Challenging a council tax reduction decision
            • When your council tax reduction starts
            • If you get council tax reduction and your circumstances change
            • Other ways to reduce your council tax bill
          • Benefits for carers
            • Carer support payment
            • Carer's allowance supplement
            • Young carer grant
            • How to challenge a Social Security Scotland decision
          • Help with heating costs
            • Child winter heating payment
            • Winter heating payment
            • Pension age winter heating payment
          • Scottish welfare fund
          • Other Scottish benefits
            • Universal credit Scottish choices
            • Funeral support payment
            • Discretionary housing payments in Scotland
            • Job start payment
        • More information about benefits in Scotland
          • Universal credit factsheets
            • Universal credit - the basics
            • Universal credit and students
            • Benefits for lone parent students
            • Kinship carers and universal credit
          • Families factsheets
            • Financial help in the early years
            • Financial help in the school years
            • Financial help for young parents
            • Parents claiming for young people in further education or training
            • Childcare costs: getting support
            • Children looked after by the local authority - impact on family benefits
            • Financial help for families fleeing domestic abuse
            • Universal credit for lone parent students
            • Financial help for families affected by imprisonment
          • Disability benefits factsheets
            • Benefits for disabled children and their families - a checklist
            • Benefits for disabled students
          • Benefits for migrants and refugees factsheets
            • Rights to benefits and tax credits for European nationals
            • EU citizen guide to claiming benefits in the UK
            • Benefits for new refugees
            • Benefits for resettled Afghans
            • Benefits for resettled Ukrainians
            • No recourse to public funds, person subject to immigration control and benefit entitlement
          • Kinship care factsheets
            • Kinship care and benefits – the essentials
            • Scottish child payment and kinship carers
            • Kinship carers and universal credit
          • Benefits for students and young people factsheets
            • Benefits for students
            • Benefits for care-experienced students
            • Benefits for disabled students
            • Benefits for young people in further education or training
            • Universal credit and students
            • Parents claiming for young people in further education or training
            • Benefits for lone parent students
            • Care-experienced young people and benefits
            • Students and carer support payment
          • Prison and benefits factsheets
            • Financial help for families affected by imprisonment
            • Prison and benefits
          • Veterans and benefits
        • Other CPAG resources on benefits in Scotland
      • Bulletins & articles
        • Welfare Rights Bulletin
        • Articles
        • eBulletins
      • Test cases
        • About legal test cases
        • Support with an Upper Tribunal case
        • Test case updates
        • Refer a test case
        • Support with the judicial review process
    • Get involved
      • Donate
        • Our supporter promise
      • Fundraise
        • Hold a fundraising event
        • Our fundraising heroes
        • Contact the fundraising team
      • A gift in your will
        • How to leave a gift in your will
        • The impact of your legacy
        • Supporter stories
          • Mike's story
          • Ruth's story
          • Gaynor's story
      • In memory
      • Membership
      • Our campaigns
      • Help our work
        • Share your experience of the benefits system
        • Advisers - tell us about your case
        • Voice network and Youth Voice
        • Tell us about your experience of Scottish child payment and other Scottish payments for families
    • Benefit rates
    • Shop
    • Training & events
    • Log in
    • CPAG Home