7. Challenging EUSS decisions
If you are refused leave under the European Union Settlement Scheme (EUSS), or you are granted pre-settled status when you think you should have received settled status, you should get urgent immigration advice about your options. Your decision letter should explain how you can challenge the decision.
Note: if you make a late application on or after 9 August 2023 and the Home Office decides you do not have reasonable grounds and therefore your application is not valid, you do not have a right to appeal this decision. If this happens, you should get urgent immigration advice. See here.
Making a new application might assist if you already have pre-settled status and you have been refused settled status because of a lack of evidence. You could consider gathering additional evidence and then making a new free-of-charge application as soon as possible.
Administrative review is no longer possible for EUSS decisions made since 5 October 2023. Applications submitted before that date are still being considered. If an administrative review results in the refusal being maintained, you can still lodge an appeal against the decision.
Appeals to the First-tier Tribunal are possible if you made a valid application under the EUSS on or after 11pm on 31 January 2020. You will have a right of appeal against a decision:
- to refuse your application on eligibility or suitability grounds; or
- to grant pre-settled status when you believe you qualify for settled status; or
- when you have settled status or pre-settled status and a relevant decision is made on or after 11pm on 31 January 2020 to cancel, curtail or revoke that leave or make a deportation order in relation to you.1
In relation to appeals, if you are in the UK when the decision is made and your removal is not certified, your leave will normally be extended while an in-time appeal is pending,2 including if your appeal is against a decision to curtail your pre-settled status (see Home Office guidance, EU Settlement Scheme: cancellation and curtailment (v1), p33). If you are told that your leave will not be extended, you should obtain urgent immigration advice, as your situation is more complex.