3. Evidence of residence rights
If you are required to provide evidence of your residence rights, you will need to provide evidence of your nationality and, if you are not a British or Irish citizen, evidence of your immigration status. For how to provide evidence of your immigration status, see here.
If you are claiming a benefit that requires a right to reside and you have pre-settled status or a pending valid European Union Settlement Scheme (EUSS) application for settled or pre-settled status, you are in a protected group that can potentially have one or more free movement residence rights (see here). In addition to evidence of this immigration status, you must also provide evidence of any free movement residence rights that you have (see here). This process can be complex and can involve several steps, each requiring certain conditions to be met. It is advisable to set out clearly to the decision maker the basis of your free movement residence rights and, wherever possible, provide evidence of every requirement. If you do not have documentary evidence for one requirement but you have provided evidence of others, the decision maker is more likely to accept your uncorroborated evidence on the remaining one (see here).
If you have pre-settled status, but no free movement rights (or only one that is excluded for the benefit you want to claim - eg, as a jobseeker when you are claiming universal credit), and if refusal of benefit would mean you are left without sufficient resources to live in dignified conditions, it may be arguable that your pre-settled status by itself can satisfy the right to reside requirement for universal credit, pension credit and housing benefit. For details of this and the steps to work through if you have pre-settled status, see here.
Residence documents issued under the EEA Regulations
You only need a residence document issued under the European Economic Area (EEA) Regulations to have a free movement right to reside if you are an extended family member (see here). In this case, you must have an EEA family permit, registration certificate or residence card, which remains in force (see below for periods since 1 July 2021), to be treated as a family member of someone who can confer a free movement right of residence on you (see here).1
For any other free movement right to reside, although you could, until the deadline (see below), apply for the residence documents issued under the EEA Regulations listed below, they were and are not necessary, because your right to reside depends on the facts of your situation. If you do hold a residence document issued under the EEA Regulations, it can only confirm your residence rights; it cannot give you a right to reside if, for example, it was issued in error or if it correctly confirmed your right to reside when it was issued, but your circumstances have now changed such that you no longer have that right to reside.2
The deadline to apply for the following residence documents was the end of the transition period (11pm on 31 December 2020),3 unless the exception for an EEA family permit applied to you, in which case the deadline to apply was 30 June 2021:
- a registration certificate, if you are an EEA national with a right of residence under the EEA Regulations;4
- a residence card, if you are a non-EEA national with a right to reside as the family member of an EEA national who either has a right to reside as a qualified person (see here) or has a permanent right of residence;5
- a derivative residence card, if you have a derivative right to reside (see here);6
- a document certifying a permanent right of residence, if you are an EEA national with a permanent right of residence, or a permanent residence card if you are a non-EEA national with permanent residency;7
- a residence document issued, or treated as issued, under previous EEA Regulations. These are treated as issued under the current EEA Regulations;8
- an EEA family permit issued for entry to the UK, if you are a family member of an EEA national with a free movement right of residence in the UK and either:9
- you applied before the end of the transition period; or
- you applied by 30 June 2021 and were in a protected group that could continue to have a free movement right to reside at the time (see here). After 31 December 2020, you could only be issued with an EEA family permit as an extended family member if you were the EEA national’s partner in a durable relationship.
Note: although you can no longer apply for these residence documents, if you applied before the deadlines above, any residence document you were then issued remains in force, provided the basis on which it was issued continues to apply. See below and get specialist advice if your entitlement is not accepted.
EEA Regulations residence documents since 1 July 2021
If you are an extended family member, to be treated as a ‘family member’ of someone who can confer a qualifying right to reside on you, you need to have been issued with one of the residence documents under the EEA Regulations listed above, and that document must remain in force (see here). It is no longer possible to apply for these documents. If you have already been issued with one, note that, at the time of writing, UK legislation and policy did not appear to provide for such documents to remain in force in all circumstances.
If you have pre-settled status, the UK government’s stated policy is that you can continue to use a residence document issued under the EEA Regulations until it expires, including to help prove entitlement to certain benefits.10 This should also apply if you have a pending valid EUSS application for settled or pre-settled status (or a pending appeal or administrative review of a refusal).
If your residence document issued under the EEA Regulations has expired, the Home Office does not issue further residence documents under the EEA Regulations. The benefit authorities may decide that you no longer satisfy the requirements to be treated as a family member specified in the EEA Regulations.11 However, it may be arguable that you should still be treated as a family member for benefit purposes, because although your residence document issued under the EEA Regulations has expired, you cannot obtain a replacement as there is no longer an application process.
If you obtained an EUSS family permit when you would have been eligible for an EEA family permit, it may be arguable that you should be treated as a family member for benefit purposes. In support of this argument, note that the Upper Tribunal held in an immigration case that an application made for an EUSS family permit could be treated as an application for an EEA family permit.12
If you are an extended family member and your benefit claim is refused or your award is terminated (eg, because your residence document has expired and cannot be replaced, or your residence document has not expired but is not accepted as remaining in force), challenge the decision and get specialist advice.
References
- 1
Reg 7(3) I(EEA) Regs
- 2
SSWP v Dias, C-325/09 [2011]; EM and KN v SSWP [2009] UKUT 44 (AAC); MD v SSWP (SPC) [2016] UKUT 319 (AAC); regs 17(8), 18(7), 19(4) and 20(5) I(EEA) Regs
- 3
See, for example, Batool and others (other family members: EU exit) [2022] UKUT 219 (IAC)
- 4
Reg 17 I(EEA) Regs; Sch 3 para 3(3) ISSC Regs
- 5
Reg 18 I(EEA) Regs; Sch 3 para 3(4) ISSC Regs
- 6
Reg 20 I(EEA) Regs; Sch 3 para 3(6) ISSC Regs
- 7
Reg 19 I(EEA) Regs; Sch 3 para 3(5) ISSC Regs
- 8
Reg 45 and Sch 6 para 2 I(EEA) Regs; reg 10 CR(ADTP) Regs
- 9
Reg 12 I(EEA) Regs; regs 3(4)-(6), 4(2) and (5)-(8) and 6(b) CR(ADTP) Regs; Sch 3 para 3(1) and (2) ISSC Regs
- 10
For example, gov.uk/uk-residence-card
- 12
Unreported linked cases EA/04026/2021 and EA/04027/2021
at tribunalsdecisions.service.gov.uk/utiac/ea-04026-2021-ea-04027-2021