4. Protected groups that can have European free movement residence rights
Since the end of the transition period (see here), you can only have a free movement right to reside if you are in one of the protected groups below. If you are in one of these groups, you can potentially have one or more free movement rights for the purpose of claiming benefits, despite these rights in general having been ended within UK law at the end of the transition period. For the legal basis of these rights, see here.
If you need a free movement right to reside to claim a benefit that requires you to have a right to reside, you need to check whether:
- you are in a protected group; and
- you have a free movement right to reside (see here), other than one that is excluded for the benefit you want to claim (see here).
For periods since 30 June 2021, you are in a protected group while you:
- have pre-settled status (see also first note below);1 or
- have made a valid application to the European Union Settlement Scheme (EUSS) for settled or pre-settled status and that application (or appeal against, or administrative review of, a refusal) has not been finally determined, withdrawn or abandoned (see also second note below).2
Note:
- If you have pre-settled status, you remain in a protected group while you have this leave – ie, during the initial five-year grant of this leave, and during any extension. However, note that you can apply for settled status as soon as you become eligible for it, and from the date you are granted settled status you have a right to reside that, by itself, satisfies the right to reside requirement for all benefits that have that requirement. For further information on moving from pre-settled to settled status, see here.
- If you have a pending valid EUSS application, the Home Office should issue you with a Certificate of Application as soon as your application is accepted as valid (see here).3 Guidance states decision makers should accept you have made a valid EUSS application if you have received a Certificate of Application.4 However, if you cannot show that you have received this (eg, if you have lost access to your online account), provide any evidence you have of your application and ask the benefit authority to confirm it directly with the Home Office.
- If you have limited leave to enter granted on the basis that you hold a EUSS family permit or travel permit (see here), you are not in a protected group until you make a valid application to the EUSS for settled or pre-settled status. Once you do, and while that application (or a pending appeal or administrative review of a refusal) is pending, you are within the second protected group in the first list above.
For information on how to provide evidence that you have either pre-settled status or a pending valid EUSS application for settled or pre-settled status, see here.
In practice, while either of the above groups apply to you, the benefit authorities will generally accept that you are in a protected group that can potentially have one or more free movement rights to reside. However, if this it is not accepted, challenge the decision, get advice and ask your adviser to contact CPAG. For further details on these protected groups, see pp196–200 of the 15th edition of this Handbook.
Between the end of 2020 and 1 July 2021, in addition to the two protected groups above, you may also have been in a protected group if you or your family member had, or were treated as having, a free movement right to reside in the UK at the end of 2020 – see pp196–200 of the 15th edition of this Handbook.
Before the end of 2020, you did not need to be in a protected group to have a free movement right to reside because free movement law continued to apply in the UK.
Transition period
The ‘transition period’ (also called the ‘implementation period’) was the period from the UK leaving the European Union (EU) at 11pm on 31 January 2020 to 11pm on 31 December 2020.5 During the transition period, in general, EU legislation and caselaw as well as all EU-derived law (eg, the European Economic Area (EEA) Regulations, which set out free movement rights in the UK – see here) continued to have effect just as they did before the UK left the EU.6 At the end of this transition period, free movement rights were, in general, ended within UK law.7 This included revoking the EEA Regulations. However, these regulations continue to have effect for the purpose of claiming benefits since the end of the transition period, if you are within a protected group (see above).
For information on how the law on free movement residence rights operates after the UK left the EU, and after the end of the transition period, see here.
Note: the UK leaving the EU also affected the EU co-ordination rules after the end of the transition period (see here).
References
- 1
Reg 83 and Sch 4 paras 1-4 ISSC Regs; ADM Memo 29/20, paras 24 and 87-114; DMG Memo 25/20, paras 23-35 and 92-119
- 2
Arts 4, 10, 13, 15 and 18(3) WA 2019; Arts 4, 9, 12, 14 and 17(3) UK-EFTA; Arts 4, 10, 12, 14 and 16(3) UK-SA; ss7A-7C EU(W)A 2018; HB Circular A10/2021; DMG Memo 14/21; ADM Memo 19/21
- 3
Art 18(1)(b) WA 2019; Art 17(1)(b) UK-EFTA; Art 16(1)(b) UK-SA
- 4
DMG Memo 14/21, para 8; ADM Memo 19/21, para 8; HB Circular A10/2021, para 12
- 5
Arts 2(e), 126 and 127 WA 2019; ss1A, 1B, 8A and Sch 2 Part 1A EU(W)A 2018
- 6
ss1A and 1B EU(W)A 2018
- 7
s1 and Sch 1 ISSCA 2020; reg 4 ISSCA(C) Regs