GEA v SSWP
Universal credit (UC) – LCWRA element – earnings threshold rule at regulation 41 of the UC Regulations
Summary
The claimant was entitled to UC. In June 2021 she declared she had limited capability for work (LCW) and provided medical evidence. Before a work capability assessment (WCA) deciding that she had limited capability for work-related activity (LCWRA) was completed in April 2022, the claimant received earnings from work in the assessment period (AP) from 3 November 2021 to 2 December 2022. The LCWRA element was only included from 3 March 2022 onwards. That was because it was decided that her earnings in the November 2021 AP exceeded the relevant earnings threshold, and therefore (as no exceptions applied), the WCA and the default three-month relevant period before the LCWRA could be included did not begin until the December AP – ie, not from June. The claimant contended that she was entitled to the LCWRA element from 3 September 2021. On appeal, the First-tier Tribunal held that although after an initial relevant period the claimant was indeed entitled to the LCWRA element from 3 September 2021, as she exceeded the earnings threshold in the November AP, she was then not entitled to the element in that period. Consequently, a second relevant period began in December, with the element only included again from March 2022.
Upper Tribunal Judge Butler allowed the claimant’s appeal and substituted a decision that the claimant was entitled to the LCWRA element in her UC from 3 September 2021. But (contrary to the claimant’s argument) that was on the basis the correct assessment of her earnings was below the relevant earnings threshold, so that any issues about the effect of the threshold on her entitlement to the element never arose. On the facts, her earnings fluctuated without an identifiable cycle and so should have been assessed using the averaging provisions in regulation 90(6)(b) (ii) of the Universal Credit Regulations 2013. The result of that was that her earnings did not exceed the threshold and the relevant period had begun in June 2021.
As the First-tier Tribunal had requested guidance, the judge went on to make extensive comment about the interaction between the earnings threshold and the LCWRA element. The rule about the earnings threshold was at regulation 41. The rule about the relevant period for inclusion of the LCWRA element is at regulation 28. Regulation 41(2) includes that where (as here) a claimant’s LCW falls to be assessed for the first time, if they have earnings that are above a specified threshold then, unless an exception (eg, entitlement to a disability benefit or terminal illness) applies, no WCA can be carried out and the claimant is to be treated as not having limited capability for work (consequently, they cannot be assessed for LCWRA either). The judge pointed out that the exceptions do not include the ‘substantial risk’ provisions. Further, where under regulation 41(2) the claimant is at or above the earnings threshold and an exception does not apply, ‘the SSWP cannot carry out an assessment and must treat them as not having LCW…’ (this also meant even if an assessment had been started, it could not be completed). But, ‘the claimant will be able to apply afresh for the SSWP to consider whether they have LCWRA…the claimant will be able to apply for this by declaring LCW and providing a MED3 fit note or equivalent, or through a combination of this and self-certification as confirmed in KS v SSWP (ULCW) [2025] UKUT 015 (AAC)’ (paragraph 88). Regarding the claimant in this case, had regulation 41(2) applied, the approach taken by the First-tier Tribunal would have been incorrect. Regulation 28 ‘does not allow claimants to move in and out of entitlement to the LCWRA’. Instead, ‘the start date for any relevant period before the LCWRA could be included’ would have been fixed by regulation 41(2) no longer applying and by the claimant ‘declaring LCW afresh’ (paragraph 91).
Comment from CPAG
The judge’s further guidance, regarding when regulation 41(2) does apply and what follows from that, might be considered obiter (ie,and so not binding), although its detail might well be regarded as persuasive. Most of that guidance is unexceptionable. But the apparent conclusion that, had regulation 41(2) applied to the claimant in the November AP, then the April 2022 WCA could not have been started or completed seems a harsh result (especially given that earnings were not an issue in June 2021) and might be questioned.