CPAG search
If you're an adviser, you might like to try our Welfare Rights search.
Pension-age claimants – income maximisation
3. Which benefits are covered
The benefits to which the co-ordination rules apply are referred to as being within the ‘material scope’ of the rules.
Each of the rules refers to categories of benefits designed to cover certain ‘risks’, such as ‘old age’ or ‘maternity’. The UK–Ireland Convention lists the benefits of each state considered to assist with each risk.1 Under the main co-ordination rules, the UK–European Union (EU) Protocol and the UK–European Free Trade Association (EFTA) Convention, most benefits are not specified in the legislation, but member states are required to provide a list of the benefits considered to assist with each risk to the administrative committee for that set of rules.2 However, the categorisation of a benefit can be challenged, because ultimately categorisation depends on the benefit’s characteristics rather than on how an individual state lists the benefit.
Benefits are also divided into the following types, depending on the conditions of eligibility:
- social security benefits (see here);
- (except under the UK–Ireland Convention) special non-contributory benefits (see here);
- social and medical assistance (social assistance under the UK–Ireland Convention) (see here).
Those benefits categorised as social security benefits have the most rights. Special non-contributory benefits provide fewer rights under the main co-ordination rules and are not covered under the UK–EU Protocol or the UK–EFTA Convention. Social and medical assistance is not covered by any of the sets of co-ordination rules, with the exception of the UK–Ireland Convention, which only covers social assistance in relation to recovery of overpayments.
References
Social security benefits
Social security benefits are categorised according to the risk against which they are designed to provide financial protection.1
The main co-ordination rules, the UK–EU Protocol and the UK–EFTA Convention do not list the benefits that assist with each risk within the legislation, but the UK–Ireland Convention does.2
The table below lists the benefits that are accepted as categorised for each risk under the main co-ordination rules and the benefits listed in the UK–Ireland Convention. Under the UK–EU Protocol, benefit categorisation should follow that of the main co-ordination rules, unless the protocol specifically provides otherwise. That is confirmed in guidance, which lists UK benefits into categories for both the main co-ordination rules and the UK–EU Protocol (but see the note on contributory employment and support allowance (ESA) below the table).3 Arguably, benefit categorisation under the UK–EFTA Convention should also follow that of the main co-ordination rules.
The UK–EU Protocol and the UK–EFTA Convention are the only sets of rules that list benefits which are not covered.
The UK–EU Protocol and the UK–EFTA Convention do not apply to:4
- family benefits;
- long-term care benefits. These are listed as attendance allowance (AA), disability living allowance (DLA) care component, personal independence payment (PIP) daily living component, carer’s allowance (CA), young carer grant and (UK–EFTA Convention only) child disability payment (CDP) care component and child winter heating payment.5 Although carer support payment (CSP), pension age disability payment (PADP), adult disability payment (ADP) daily living component, Scottish adult disability living allowance (SADLA) and, under the UK–EU Protocol, CDP care component and child winter heating payment are not listed, each is treated as a long-term care benefit;
- winter fuel, heating or cold weather payments;
- special non-contributory benefits (see here);
- social and medical assistance (see here).
| Risk | UK benefits listed under main co-ordination rules | UK benefits listed under UK–Ireland Convention |
|---|---|---|
| Sickness | AA/PADP CA/CSP DLA/CDP/SADLA care component PIP/ADP daily living component Young carer grant Child winter heating payment Statutory sick pay ESA in the assessment phase or for the first 365 days (see the note below) | ESA in the assessment phase |
| Long-term care benefits | Treated as sickness benefits6 | AA DLA care component PIP daily living component CA (CSP, PADP, ADP daily living component, SADLA/CDP care component are not listed but are treated as long-term care benefits) |
| Maternity and paternity | Maternity allowance (MA) Statutory maternity, adoption, paternity, shared parental pay, neonatal care and parental bereavement pay (see here) | MA |
| Invalidity | AA, DLA care and mobility components and CA if your entitlement began before 1 June 1992. Long-term incapacity benefit Severe disablement allowance ESA after the assessment phase or after the first 365 days (or arguably before - see the note below) | ESA after the assessment phase |
| Old age | State pension Category A, B and D retirement pensions Additional pension Graduated retirement benefit Increments – eg, to pensions Age addition in pensions | State retirement pension |
| Pre-retirement | None | None |
| Survivors | Bereavement benefits | Widow’s pension Widowed parent’s allowance |
| Death grants | Bereavement support payment (lump-sum payment) | Bereavement support payment |
| Accidents at work and occupational diseases | Industrial injuries disablement benefit Constant attendance allowance Exceptionally severe disablement allowance Reduced earnings allowance Retirement allowance | Industrial injuries benefits |
| Unemployment | Jobseeker’s allowance (JSA) | JSA |
| Family benefits (see here) | Child benefit Guardian’s allowance Increases in other benefits for an adult or a child | Child benefit Guardian’s allowance |
Note:
- Under the main co-ordination rules, ESA is classed initially as a sickness benefit during (in older DWP guidance) the 91-day assessment phase,7 and (in more recent DWP guidance) the first 365 days,8 then as an invalidity benefit thereafter. Under the UK–EU Protocol and UK–EFTA Convention, DWP guidance classes ESA as an invalidity benefit from the outset. This is significant because invalidity benefits cannot be exported under the protocol or convention.9
- The DWP considers universal credit (UC) to be neither a social security nor a special non-contributory benefit.10 The Supreme Court recently held that the child element of UC is not a family benefit under the main co-ordination rules, as those rules do not provide for it to be severed from the whole of UC, which itself is not a social security benefit under those rules.11 UC is listed as ‘social assistance’ in the UK–Ireland Convention (see here).
- It may be arguable that winter fuel payment and pension age winter heating payment should be classed as old age benefits under the main co-ordination rules and the UK–Ireland Convention, and therefore potentially exportable if you are habitually resident in specific EEA countries (see here).
Disability and carers’ benefits
Under the main co-ordination rules, AA, PADP, the care component of DLA, CDP and SADLA, the daily living component of PIP and ADP, CSP, CA and young carer grant are categorised as sickness benefits. (For the previous changing categorisations of these benefits and the relevance of this for being paid in an European Economic Area (EEA) state if your entitlement began before 2013, see here.)
The mobility component of DLA continues to be listed as a special non-contributory benefit and that has been held to be lawful.12 The mobility components of PIP, ADP, SADLA and CDP are each accepted as special non-contributory benefits (see below).
The UK–Ireland Convention categorises AA, DLA care component, PIP daily living component and CA as long-term care benefits, but then treats them in broadly the same way as sickness benefits are treated under the main co-ordination rules.13 Although ADP daily living component, CDP care component, SADLA care component, CSP and young carer grant are not listed under the convention, it applies in similar ways and the regulations enable you to continue to receive, or (except SADLA) make a new claim for, these benefits while resident in Ireland in certain circumstances if you are covered by the convention (see here).14 The mobility components of DLA, SADLA, CDP, PIP and ADP are not referred to at all.
The UK–EU Protocol and UK–EFTA Convention categorise AA, DLA care component, PIP daily living component, CA, young carer grant and (UK–EFTA Convention only) CDP and child winter heating payment as long-term care benefits, and the mobility components of DLA and PIP as special non-contributory benefits, and lists both categories as ones to which the protocol does not apply.15 Although ADP, PADP, SADLA and CSP are not listed under either the protocol or convention, and CDP is not listed under the protocol, CSP, PADP, SADLA care component, ADP daily living component (and, under the protocol, CDP care component) are treated as long-term care benefits, and the mobility components are treated (or, under the convention, CDP mobility component is listed) as special non-contributory benefits, therefore neither component of ADP or SADLA or CDP, nor CSP nor PADP, are covered by the protocol or the convention.
References
- 1
Art 3 EU Reg 883/04; Art 3 UK-IC; Art SSC3 UK-EUP; Art 6 UK-EFTAC
- 2
Art 3 UK-IC
- 3
DWPWAG, Fig 4
- 4
Art SSC3(4) UK-EUP; Art 6(5) UK-EFTAC
- 5
Annex SSC-1 Part 2(i) UK-EUP; Annex 2 Part 2 UK-EFTAC
- 6
Confirmed in Art 34 EU Reg 883/04
- 7
Vol 2 Ch 7 Part 1 paras 070152, 070280 and 070401 and Appendix para 18 DMG; paras C4119 and C4153 ADM
- 8
DWPWAG, Fig 4
- 9
DWPWAG, Fig 4; ADM Memo 8/24 para 14(3); Arts SSC3(1) and SSC8 UK-EUP; Arts 6(1)(3) and 11 UK-EFTAC
- 10
SSAC, Universal Credit and Related Regulations Report and Government Response, December 2012
- 11
Simkova v SSWP [2025] UKSC 41
- 12
Bartlett and Others v SSWP, C-537/09 [2011]
- 13
Arts 3, 16, 19 and 20 UK-IC
- 14
ADP Reg 15(3) and (4) DAWAP(S) Regs
CAS s81(2A) and (13) SS(S)A 2018
CDP Reg 5(4)-(5) DACYP(S) Regs
CSP Reg 6(3)-(4) CA(CSP)(S) Regs
PADP Reg 9(3)-(4) DAOP(S) Regs SADLA Reg 10(3)-(4) DA(SADLA) Regs
YCG Reg 8(3) and (6) CA(YCG)(S) Regs
- 15
Art SSC3(4)(a) and (d), and Annex SSC-1, Part 1(i)(c) and (d), and Part 2(i) UK-EUP; Art 6(5)(a) and (d), and Annex 2, Parts 1 and 2 UK-EFTAC
Special non-contributory benefits
The main EU co-ordination rules, the UK–EU Protocol and the UK–EFTA Convention define ‘special non-contributory benefits’ as:1
- intended to provide supplementary or ancillary cover against the risks on here and guarantee a minimum subsistence income, or provide specific protection for disabled people closely linked to a person’s social environment in the state concerned; and
- funded solely from general taxation and not dependent on having made contributions as a condition of entitlement; and
- listed as such by each state in an annex to main legislation.
In the main EU co-ordination rules, the UK government has only listed pension credit (PC) and the mobility component of DLA as special non-contributory benefits.2 However, the mobility component of PIP is also accepted as a special non-contributory benefit,3 and the mobility components of CDP, SADLA and ADP are also treated as such.4 Scottish child payment, funeral support payment, Best Start grants and Best Start food payments have also been categorised as special non-contributory benefits.
Under the UK–EU Protocol and UK–EFTA Convention, all the above benefits are listed or treated as special non-contributory benefits.5
The main co-ordination rules state that special non-contributory benefits can only be paid in the state in which you are ‘resident’6 under the legislation, and at the expense of that state (see here for details of when you count as resident). However, although you cannot ‘export’ special non-contributory benefits, all the other co-ordination principles apply.7
In contrast, under the UK–EU Protocol and UK–EFTA Convention, none of the principles apply because each lists special non-contributory benefits as benefits to which it does not apply.8
The UK–Ireland Convention does not refer to special non-contributory benefits at all, but defines the three means-tested benefits as ‘social assistance’ (see below) and does not refer to the others at all.
References
- 1
Art 70(1) and (2) and Annex X EU Reg 883/04; Art SSC1(bb) and Annex SSC-1 Part 1 UK-EUP; Art 1(kk) and Annex 2 Part 1 UK-EFTAC
- 2
Annex X EU Reg 883/04
- 3
SSWP v DS [2019] UKUT 238 (AAC); para C2097 and Appendix 1 para 4 ADM
- 4
’EU rules on social security co-ordination’ in ADP, CDP and SADLA SSS DMG (R and P) SSS DMG
- 5
Annex SSC-1 Part 1 UK-EUP; Annex 2 Part 1 UK-EFTAC
- 6
Art 70 EU Reg 883/04; see also Bartlett and Others v SSWP, C-537/09 [2011] and Swaddling v AO, C-90/97 [1999]
- 7
Art 3(3) EU Reg 883/04; Dano v Jobcenter Leipzig, C-333/13 [2014], paras 46-55
- 8
Art SSC3(4)(a) and Annex SSC-1 Part 1 UK-EUP; Art 6(5)(a) and Annex 2 Part 1 UK-EFTAC
Social and medical assistance
Under the main co-ordination rules, the UK–EU Protocol and the UK–EFTA Convention, benefits which are neither ‘social security’ nor ‘special non-contributory’ benefits are considered to be social assistance and are excluded from the co-ordination rules.1
The UK government does not specify which benefits it considers to be social assistance under any of these sets of rules, but has made it clear that it does not consider UC to be either a social security or a special non-contributory benefit.2 When the Supreme Court recently held that the child element of UC is not a family benefit under the main co-ordination rules, it was not necessary to decide whether UC as a whole is social assistance because all parties agreed that it is not a social security benefit.3
It has also been decided that housing benefit4 is not a social security or special non-contributory benefit. The Scottish government has categorised job start payment as social assistance.
Under the UK–Ireland Convention, ‘social assistance’ is defined in relation to UK benefits as UC and PC.5 The only provisions made by the convention for social assistance relate to the recovery of overpayments. If you, or members of your family, have received social assistance in the UK while you were entitled to that assistance under Irish legislation, the convention provides for the UK to request that the Irish benefit authorities recover this ‘overpayment’ from ongoing payments of the Irish benefit and then forward that to the UK (and vice versa).6
4. Principles of co-ordination
The co-ordination rules set out several general principles (see here). These principles are often the starting point in deciding how the co-ordination rules affect your entitlement.1 However, there are exceptions to these principles for specific categories of benefits and, in some cases, there are more detailed provisions on how the principles should apply in certain circumstances. The following information is an overview, because it is beyond the scope of this Handbook to cover all the exceptions and additional provisions in detail. You should get specialist advice about the ways in which the co-ordination rules apply to your particular circumstances.
References
- 1
For example, see J McG v (1) SSWP, (2) HMRC [2018] UKUT 2 (AAC), paras 19-24
The single competent state
In general, under each set of the co-ordination rules you can only claim a particular category of benefit from one member state, and are only liable to pay insurance contributions to one state, at any one time. This is the general principle that you can only be subject to the legislation of a single member state.1 Note: the UK–Ireland Convention refers to the ‘parties’ of the UK and Ireland rather than ‘states’, and ‘competent party’ rather than ‘competent state’, but the same principle applies.
The competent state and competent institution
The ‘competent state’ is the state responsible for paying your benefit and to which you are liable to pay insurance contributions. It is the state in which the ‘competent institution’ is situated.2
The ‘competent institution’ is broadly the institution responsible for paying your benefit and to which you are liable to pay insurance contributions.3 In the UK, the competent institutions are the DWP and HMRC.
The general rule is that the competent state is the one in which you are:4
- employed or self-employed (see the notes below); or
- a civil servant; or
- (other than for the UK–European Union (EU) Protocol or UK–European Free Trade Association (EFTA) Convention) resident while receiving an unemployment benefit under specific provisions;5 or
- (other than for the UK–EU Protocol) a conscripted member of the armed forces or someone doing compulsory civilian service.
If none of the above bullet points apply, the competent state is your state of residence (see here for how this is determined). However, this is qualified with the words ‘without prejudice to other provisions of’ the relevant set of rules guaranteeing you benefits under the legislation of one or more other member states.6 The interpretation of these qualifying words in the main co-ordination rules (and the old co-ordination rules) has been the subject of considerable caselaw, particularly in relation to sickness benefits. For details, if you are covered by the main co-ordination rules, and you are claiming a sickness benefit, see here, and if you are claiming a family benefit, see here.
If you are only covered by the UK–EU Protocol or the UK–EFTA Convention, note that the benefits classed as sickness benefits under the main co-ordination rules, and family benefits, are not covered by either set of rules.
Note:
- For your competent state to be determined on the basis of your employment or self-employment, your earnings do not need to exceed the threshold at which you are liable to pay insurance contributions.7
- You are treated as still employed or self-employed if, as a result of that activity, you are receiving cash benefits (other than for the risks of old age, occupational diseases and accidents at work or, except under the UK–Ireland Convention, invalidity, sickness or being a survivor).8
- If you work simultaneously in the UK and one or more of the European Economic Area (EEA) states, you are subject to the legislation of the state of residence if you pursue a substantial part (generally, at least 25 per cent) of your activities there.9
- If your employer’s business is normally in one state, but you are sent to another state to work and the posting is anticipated to last for no more than 24 months, you remain subject to the legislation of the first state. Similarly, if you are self-employed in one state and go to another state to pursue a similar activity as a self-employed person, you remain subject to the legislation of the first state, provided the anticipated duration of your activity in the other state is not more than 24 months.10 Under the UK–EU Protocol and UK–EFTA Convention you are referred to as a ‘detached worker’, and all the EU states have opted in to follow these rules in relation to the UK.11
- If you have moved to another EEA state, you may continue to be subject to the legislation of the state where you previously lived and were self-employed if you continue to be self-employed in that previous state.12
- If you make a claim, declaration or appeal to the institution in a state that takes the view it is not your competent state, it must forward your claim (or declaration or appeal) without delay to the relevant institution of the state the institution considers is competent. Your claim, declaration or appeal is treated as if it had been submitted to the competent state on the date it was originally submitted.13 For further information, including if there is a dispute between states over which is your competent state, see here.
How residence is determined
’Residence’ is defined in each of the co-ordination rules as ‘the place where a person habitually resides’.14 The Withdrawal Agreements cross-refer to this definition in the main co-ordination rules for the purpose of determining who is covered by Withdrawal Agreement protections (see here).15
Under the UK–Ireland Convention, this term is interpreted in accordance with the legislation of the state in which you reside.16
Under the main co-ordination rules, the UK–EU Protocol and the UK–EFTA Convention, the following factors should be considered when determining where you habitually reside. Although this list of factors is in a rule that explains what should be done if there is a difference of views between two states or institutions about where you are resident, it should also be used if there is no such dispute. Firstly, where your centre of interests lies should be agreed. This is based on an overall assessment of the relevant facts, including:17
- the duration and continuity of presence in the state(s) concerned;
- your personal situation, including:
- the nature and specific characteristics of any activity you do, in particular the place where you habitually do it, the stability of the activity and the duration of any work contract;
- your family status and family ties;
- any unpaid activity, such as voluntary work;
- if you are a student, the source of your income;
- your housing situation, in particular how permanent it is;
- the member state in which you are deemed to reside for tax purposes.
If there is still a dispute about your place of residence, your intentions should be considered, especially the reasons why you moved. That is decisive in establishing your actual place of residence.18
If there is a dispute between states over which is your competent state, see here.
When the competent state changes
If you are subject to the legislation of a member state, it continues to be your competent state until a change means that another member state becomes competent.19
The main factors that change the competent state are if:
- you start to work in another member state;20 or
- in some circumstances, you move to another member state and become resident there.
When the competent state changes can be affected by which co-ordination rules you are covered by and the category of benefit being paid. For example, the Court of Appeal held that, under the main co-ordination rules, the UK ceased to be the competent state for child benefit when the claimant moved, with her child, to reside in Spain. Consequently, entitlement to child benefit ceased, and this was not altered by the UK continuing to be the competent state for the child’s disability living allowance (DLA) care component, which is a different category of benefit.21
In general, under each of the co-ordination rules, if you continue to be entitled to a UK benefit when you move to an EEA state, the UK remains the competent state for paying that benefit until either you become employed/self-employed in the other state or, in certain circumstances, you start to receive a benefit from that state (see here).22 If it is a member of your family that starts working in the EEA state you have moved to, this should not change the competent state (see here).23 If you were self-employed in the UK and it is accepted that you continue to be so when you move to live in an EEA state, the UK remains your competent state.24
If you are covered by the main co-ordination rules and receiving a sickness benefit from the UK and also a pension from the UK, and you move to an EEA country, the Upper Tribunal confirmed that the UK remains your competent state (unless you start work in the country you have moved to). The claimant in that case was held to have continued to be entitled to the care component of DLA when she moved from the UK to Finland because she was receiving contributory employment and support allowance (ESA) (the same decision also held that when her entitlement to contributory ESA expired after a year, she continued to be entitled to DLA care component while living in Finland).25 However, recent caselaw may mean that the UK would only continue to be the competent state, while ESA was in payment, if there was no entitlement to a sickness benefit from the new state of residence (Finland) (see note below). Guidance on Scottish sickness benefits suggests entitlement continues for the remaining duration of an award if the claimant moves from Scotland to an EEA state, but that a new claim would then be directed to the benefit authorities in the EEA state as that state has become the competent state on the basis of residence.26
Note: there have been significant caselaw developments about the competent state under the main co-ordination rules for sickness benefits in the last few years (see here), and not all of the DWP’s guidance has been updated. Also, at the time of writing, there had been no caselaw on the competent state under the UK–Ireland Convention, the UK–EU Protocol or the UK–EFTA Convention. If your UK benefit claim is refused, or your award terminated, on the basis that the UK has ceased to be the competent state, challenge that decision, get advice and ask your adviser to contact CPAG.
If the decision maker decides a different state is competent
If the state in which you claim benefit decides it is not the competent state to pay that category of benefit, it must forward the claim to the relevant institution in the state that is considered competent without delay, unless there is evidence that the state takes a different view. The date you submitted your claim (or appeal) to a state that is not competent is treated as your date of claim (or appeal) by the state that is competent.26
If there is a difference of views between the institutions of two (or more) states on which is the competent state for paying a cash benefit or meeting the cost of a benefit in kind, while the issue is being resolved you can get provisional payments if you meet the other rules of entitlement. These payments are made by, and under the legislation of, the state in which you are resident (or, for family benefits under the UK–Ireland Convention, the state in which the child resides27) or (other than under the UK–Ireland Convention) the state where you first applied if you are not resident in any of the states concerned.28
If no agreement is reached between the states after one month, the matter may be referred to the EU Administrative Commission (under the main co-ordination rules) or the UK–EU Specialised Committee on Citizens’ Rights (under the UK–EU Protocol) or the Joint Administrative Committee (under the UK–EFTA Convention), which aims to reconcile disputes (other than under the UK–EFTA Convention, which does not specify a timescale) within six months.29 Under the UK–Ireland Convention, disputes are resolved by an arbitration tribunal.30
If it is determined that the state that made provisional payments is not the competent state, it can be reimbursed by the state that is competent, if the latter has a comparable benefit.31
Caselaw decided under the main co-ordination rules has established the following points about provisional payments. The rules on provisional payments apply if forwarding your claim triggers a different view and also if there is evidence of a different view when the claim is received, in which case it should not be forwarded.32 The legislation only requires there to be a ‘difference of views’ and does not mention the form in which the view must be expressed, nor the evidence required to prove the difference. If you have written confirmation that the institution of another state takes a different view of which state is competent, provide that to the decision maker (or tribunal). The Court of Appeal has held that oral evidence can be accepted if it is sufficient to satisfy the decision maker (or tribunal) that two states hold different views on the issue of competence. The Court of Appeal has also confirmed that the requirement to make provisional payments is unaffected by whether a comparable benefit is paid in the other state or whether the payments would be recouped.33 In a subsequent case, the Upper Tribunal held that there was no evidence of a difference of view but, before the claimant’s appeal to the Court of Appeal was heard, the DWP accepted that there was evidence of a difference of view and paid DLA care component on a provisional basis, despite the other state not having a comparable benefit.34
Note: even if there is clear evidence of a difference of views, benefit authorities do not always comply with their duty to make provisional payments. You may need to request these in writing, citing the relevant legislation and caselaw.
In most cases, the issue is which state is competent to make the payment, but if there is a difference of views between states on which legislation applies, you are provisionally subject to the legislation of one state, in the following order of priority:35
- if you only work in one state, the state where you work;
- if you either work in two or more states and live in one of them, or do not work, the state where you reside;
- (except under the UK–Ireland Convention) in all other cases, of the states in which you work, the state to which you first applied.
Sickness benefits
Under the main co-ordination rules, attendance allowance (AA), pension age disability payment (PADP), the daily living components of personal independence payment (PIP) and adult disability payment (ADP), the care components of DLA, child disability payment (CDP) and Scottish adult disability living allowance (SADLA), carer’s allowance (CA), carer support payment (CSP) and young carer grant are classed, or treated, as sickness benefits (see here).
If you are covered by the main co-ordination rules (see here), the UK must be the competent state for paying your sickness benefits for you to be entitled to:35
- AA, PADP, the daily living component of PIP or ADP, the care component of DLA, CDP or SADLA, CA or CSP - whether you are resident in the UK or an EEA state; or
- a young carer grant - if you are resident in an EEA state.
If you are relying on the UK–Ireland Convention to be entitled to the above benefits, there are broadly similar competent state requirements. In this Handbook, the above benefits are referred to as ‘sickness benefits’ when explaining the rules on the competent state, whether referring to the main co-ordination rules or UK–Ireland Convention. However, note that the convention uses the term ‘long-term care benefits’, lists them as AA, DLA care component, PIP daily living component and CA, and treats them in broadly the same way as sickness benefits are treated under the main co-ordination rules.36 Although not listed under the convention, the regulations for PADP, CSP, young carer grant, the daily living component of ADP and the care compenent of SADLA and CDP require the UK to be the competent state under the convention for you to be entitled if you are resident in Ireland (see here).37
Note:
- The UK must be the competent state to pay your sickness benefits. So, for example, for you to receive CA, the UK must be the competent state to pay you CA, even if there is a different competent state for paying a sickness benefit to the person for whom you care.38
- The requirement for the UK to be your competent state does not apply to the mobility components of PIP, ADP, DLA, SADLA or CDP. Under the main co-ordination rules, this is because these are classed as ‘special non-contributory benefits’ (rather than sickness benefits), which can only be paid by the state in which you are resident (see here). Under the UK–Ireland Convention, this is because the mobility components are not covered at all. Consequently, if you reside in the UK, but you are not entitled to PIP or ADP daily living component, or DLA, SADLA or CDP care component, because the UK is not the competent state to pay these benefits (eg, because although you reside in the UK, you work in another member state), you may still be entitled to the mobility component.
The UK–EU Protocol and UK–EFTA Convention do not cover either the above sickness benefits or mobility components are all (see here).39
Determining the competent state for sickness benefits
You only need to determine the competent state for the sickness benefits listed above if you are covered by the main co-ordination rules or the UK–Ireland Convention. These benefits are not covered by the UK–EU Protocol or the UK–EFTA Convention.
The competent state to pay your sickness benefits is determined under the general rule explained on here.
If you are undertaking activity as an employed or self-employed person in the UK, the UK is the competent state for paying sickness benefits, and this is confirmed in DWP guidance.39
If you are not working and none of the other bullet points listed on here apply, the competent state, in general, is your state of residence (see here for how this is determined). However, this general provision is qualified with the words ‘without prejudice to other provisions of’ the rules guaranteeing you benefits under the legislation of one or more other member states.40 ‘Other provisions’ can potentially apply if either a member of your family works in, or you (or a member of your family) receive a pension from, a member state other than the one in which you are resident. However, recent caselaw (summarised on here and here) has held that these ‘other provisions’ do not prevent entitlement to sickness benefit from the state that is competent on the basis of residence.
Therefore, if you are resident in the UK and are, or would be if not considering the competent state rules, entitled to a UK sickness benefit, the UK should be accepted as your competent state.
The exception, when these ‘other provisions’ may mean that a state other than your state of residence is competent, is if you are not entitled to a sickness benefit from your state of residence, but you are entitled to a sickness benefit from the state from which you (or a member of your family) receive a pension, or the state in which a member of your family works. For example, if you live in an EEA state, receive a pension only from the UK, and are not entitled to a sickness benefit from the EEA state, you may then be entitled to a UK sickness benefit.
Challenge decisions based on previous approach
At the time of writing, some decisions on UK sickness benefits were failing to take account of the recent caselaw and were instead determining the competent state on the basis of the previous order of priority, as follows.
1. The state in which you are working.
2. The state from which you are receiving a pension.
3. The state in which a member of your family is working.
4. The state from which a member of your family is receiving a pension.
5. The state in which you are residing.
This order of priority is no longer correct but, at the time of writing, remained on the gov.uk website.41 If you are resident in the UK, not working and your sickness benefit claim is refused, or your award terminated, on the basis that the competent state is not the UK but is the state that pays your (or a member of your family’s) pension or the state in which a member of your family is working (ie, if it appears that the decision maker has followed the above hierarchy), you should challenge the decision on the basis of the recent caselaw and guidance (summarised on here and here). It may help to note that the guidance on the effect of the Court of Appeal decision states that decision makers should cease to follow the above priority list.42
At the time of writing, the guidance on ADP, PADP, SADLA, CDP and CSP had also not been updated to take account of the recent caselaw and continued, incorrectly, to assert that receipt of an EEA pension takes priority over residence, and for CDP, that a member of the family working or receiving pension from an EEA state takes priority over the child’s state of residence.43
If your UK sickness benefit was refused or terminated since the recent caselaw – because the decision maker did not apply it – you can ask for the decision to be revised due to official error.
If a member of your family works in another member state
If you are covered by the main co-ordination rules, you are not working (and none of the other bullet points listed on here apply) and a member of your family (see here) is working in another member state, your competent state is:
- your state of residence, if you are entitled to a sickness benefit from that state; or
- the state in which the member of your family is working, if you would be entitled to a sickness benefit from that state but you are not so entitled from the state in which you are resident.
This has applied since the Court of Appeal’s judgment of 21 April 2023, which overturned earlier caselaw. The case concerned a child who had been held to be not entitled to DLA care component despite residing in the UK (with her mother who had ceased working) because her father was self-employed in Belgium, therefore Belgium rather than the UK was held to be the competent state. This reasoning was based on Article 21 of the main co-ordination rules, which provides that an insured person and members of their family residing or staying in a state other than the competent state shall be entitled to cash benefits provided by the competent state.43 The Upper Tribunal had held that since the child’s father was insured in Belgium, Article 21 took priority and resulted in Belgium being the competent state to pay the child’s sickness benefits.44 However, the Court of Appeal held that the child was entitled to DLA care component under the legislation of the UK, which was the competent state on the basis of her residence, and there was no basis under the main co-ordination rules for prioritising any rights she may derive from her father under the legislation of the state where he was self-employed (Belgium).45 The DWP published guidance summarising the effect of the Court of Appeal decision, with examples.46
If you or a member of your family receive a pension from another member state
If you are covered by the main co-ordination rules, you are not working (and none of the other bullet points listed on here apply) and you, or the member of your family who brings you within the main co-ordination rules, receive a pension (see below) from a member state other than the one in which you reside, your competent state is:
- your state of residence, if you are entitled to a sickness benefit from that state; or
- the state from which you (or a member of your family) receive the pension, if you are not entitled to sickness benefit from the state in which you are resident; or
- one of the states from which you (or a member of your family) receive a pension, if more than one state pays a pension and you are not entitled to sickness benefit from the state in which you are resident.
This has applied since the Upper Tribunal’s judgment of 5 December 2024. The case concerned a claimant’s entitlement to CA while residing in the UK. The Upper Tribunal applied the reasoning of the Court of Appeal decision summarised above, and held that the claimant’s entitlement to CA from the UK, which was the competent state on the basis of her residence, was not affected by her husband receiving a pension from Switzerland.46
This reasoning, that receipt of a pension does not prevent entitlement from the state that is competent on the basis of residence, also means that if you reside in the UK, your entitlement to a UK sickness benefit is not affected by you receiving a pension from an EEA state. This has been accepted by the First-tier Tribunal (and the DWP did not appeal), by the Upper Tribunal47 and is confirmed in DWP guidance.48
Note: in 2023, two separate decisions of the Northern Irish Commissioner held that the UK, as the state of residence, was the competent state to pay a sickness benefit despite the claimant receiving a pension from another member state.49 In each case, the Department for Communities conceded that the UK was the competent state, and consequently, the Upper Tribunal took the view these cases have limited persuasive value.50 However, equivalent guidance has been issued by the Department for Communities in Northern Ireland, based on the earlier of the two decisions, dated 27 September 2023.51
Guidance confirms that the claims and reconsideration requests should be determined in accordance with the above caselaw and that affected cases will be identified and reviewed.52 However, this does not prevent you challenging a decision to refuse your claim for, or terminate your award of, a UK sickness benefit, if it did not correctly take account of the above caselaw.
Although the caselaw above held that receipt of a pension does not prevent entitlement to a sickness benefit from the state that is competent on the basis of residence, provisions of the main co-ordination rules can assist you to be entitled to a sickness benefit from a different member state if you are not entitled from your state of residence. For details and some scenarios, see below.
If you are covered by the UK–Ireland Convention and you, or a member of your family, receive a pension, the competent state is:53
- the state in which you, or the member of your family who receives the pension, are employed or self-employed; or
- if the bullet point above does not apply, the state:
- that pays the pension, if there is only one pension in payment; or
- in which you were subject to the legislation for longest, if both the UK and Ireland are paying a pension. If the relevant periods are the same, it is the state to whose legislation you (or the member of your family who receives the pension) were subject most recently.
Note: at the time of writing, there had not been any published caselaw on the above provisions of the UK–Ireland Convention. If its application results in your claim for a sickness benefit being refused or terminated, challenge the decision, get advice and ask your adviser to contact CPAG to assist with arguments that the principles in caselaw above can apply to the convention.
Pension and pensioner
’Pension’, for the purpose of the main co-ordination rules, includes more than old age pensions. It includes lump-sum benefits that can be substituted for pensions and reimbursement of contributions, and can include revaluation increases and supplementary allowances.54 It refers to state payments made under the legislation of an EEA state and does not include private or occupational pensions. Under the old co-ordination rules, it was accepted that a pension can include incapacity benefit (IB), ESA, DLA and severe disablement allowance (SDA).55 However, a more recent case has held that the care component of DLA is not a pension under the current co-ordination rules. It also held that the term ‘pension’ must have the same meaning throughout the EU regulations and that a Dutch survivor’s benefit is a pension.56 A further case confirmed that the mobility component of DLA is also not a pension.57 It may be arguable that the term ‘pension’ includes pension credit (PC) since this is a supplementary allowance.58 Although the Upper Tribunal commented that PC is not a pension, as it is a special non-contributory benefit (see here),59 the argument was not considered in depth, and the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has held that a benefit can be both a special non-contributory benefit and a supplementary allowance.60 However, the most recent Upper Tribunal decisions have focused on the need for a benefit to be contributory for it to be considered a pension61 (although contributory ESA awarded on conversion from IB in youth was still accepted as a pension, despite the claimant’s not having paid contributions).62 DWP guidance confirms that receipt of ESA, IB, SDA, retirement pension (other than category D), industrial injuries disablement benefit and bereavement benefit (other than a lump-sum bereavement support payment) are all considered UK pensions.63 Note: it is strongly arguable that the guidance is wrong to exclude a category D pension, and that this should count as a pension. If this is the reason for you being refused a sickness benefit, challenge that decision and get advice to argue that your category D pension means that the UK is your competent state.
The Department for Communities (Northern Ireland) argued that invalidity pension, an Irish contributory benefit, was a pension for the purpose of determining the competent state but, when asked by the Northern Irish Commissioner for the legal basis of this, abandoned this submission.64
Under the UK–Ireland Convention, ‘pension’ is defined as an old age benefit, invalidity benefit or a survivor’s benefit.65
’Pensioner’ is not defined under the main co-ordination rules, but refers to someone receiving a pension.66
Under the UK–Ireland Convention, ‘pensioner’ is defined as a person receiving a pension.67
Scenarios if a pension is paid by another member state
If you are covered by the UK–Ireland Convention and you, or a member of your family, receive a pension, see above.
If you are covered by the main co-ordination rules, and you or a member of your family (see here) receive a pension (see above) from a member state other than the state in which you reside, use the scenarios below to determine which state is competent for paying your sickness benefits.
The main co-ordination rules include provisions, if a pension is in payment, for the competent state for paying your cash sickness benefits to be the state responsible for meeting the cost of your ‘sickness benefits in kind’ - ie, your healthcare (eg, in the UK, NHS treatment).65 Although you receive sickness benefits in kind in the state where you are resident, the cost of these treatments can be borne by another state. This means that, to work out which state is competent to pay a cash sickness benefit, you may need to establish which state is responsible for the cost of sickness benefits in kind. However, recent caselaw (summarised above) has held that these provisions do not prevent you from being entitled to sickness benefits from the state in which you reside (see scenario 1).
Note: if you are working, the state in which you are employed or self-employed is your competent state (see here). This is not affected by receipt of a pension. The DWP has accepted for many years that undertaking activity as an employed or self-employed person in the UK is sufficient to mean that the UK is the competent state for paying sickness benefits.66
Scenario 1: If you reside in the UK and you, or a member of your family, receive a pension from an EEA state, the UK , as your state of residence, is the competent state to pay your sickness benefits, and this is not affected by receipt of a pension.
Example
Maja is a Danish national who lived and worked in the UK from 2017 until two months ago, when she began to receive her Danish retirement pension. She has settled status and continues to reside in the UK. As soon as she stopped work, she made a claim for AA. The DWP accepts that Maja is covered by the Withdrawal Agreement protections on the basis of her having been subject to the legislation of the UK on and since 31 December 2020 and having settled status. She is covered by the main co-ordination rules as an EEA national who has been subject to the legislation of at least one member state and moved between them. The DWP accepts that, as her claim has been made after 5 December 2024 (the date of the recent Upper Tribunal decision67), the UK is her competent state as it is her state of residence. Maja is awarded AA.68
Scenario 2: If you reside in an EEA state and receive only a UK pension, the UK is responsible for the cost of your sickness benefits in kind. Therefore, if you are not entitled to a sickness benefit from the EEA state in which you reside, you can be entitled to UK sickness benefits.
Guidance for decision makers confirms you can continue to be entitled to (’export’), or make a new claim for, a UK sickness benefit if you live in an EEA state and receive a UK pension.69 Guidance covers examples of these rules applying to claimants living in EEA states.
- The receipt of a UK pension by a French national residing in France means the competent state to pay their cash sickness benefits is the UK, therefore they are able to receive AA.70
- The receipt of a UK pension by a UK national (or member of their family) residing in an EEA state means the competent state to pay sickness benefits is the UK, therefore they can make a new claim for a UK sickness benefit, provided the claimant does not meet the criteria for the sickness benefit in the EEA state where they reside.71
Scenario 3: If you receive a pension from two or more states and one of them is the state in which you reside, that state is responsible for the cost of your sickness benefits in kind and is therefore the competent state for paying sickness benefits.72
Example
Willem is a Dutch national with settled status who has been living and working in the UK since 2018. Five months ago, he stopped work due to health problems and was awarded ESA. Three months ago he began receiving a small Dutch pension. Last month he made a claim for the daily living component of PIP. Willem is covered by the Withdrawal Agreement protections on the basis of his having been subject to the legislation of the UK on and since 31 December 2020 (due to working and then in receipt of ESA). He is covered by the main co-ordination rules as an EEA national who has been subject to the legislation of at least one member state and moved between them. The DWP has accepted for many years that his ESA is classed as a ‘pension’ (see here) and therefore receipt of ESA by Willem who resides in the UK means that, despite his receiving a pension from the Netherlands, the UK is the competent state to pay his sickness benefits.73
Scenario 4: If you receive a pension from two or more states, and do not reside in either of them, the state that is responsible for the cost of your sickness benefits in kind is the state in which you were subject to pensions legislation for the longest period (or if that is more than one state, the state in which you were last subject to its pensions legislation).74 Therefore, that is the state from which you may be entitled to sickness benefits, unless you are entitled to a sickness benefit from the EEA state in which you reside.
Scenario 5: If you are a member of the family of a person receiving a pension and reside in a different state to them (and do not receive your own pension), the state that pays their pension must meet the cost of the sickness benefits in kind for them and must also meet the cost of sickness benefits in kind for you.75 Therefore, that is the state from which you may be entitled to sickness benefits, unless you are entitled to a sickness benefit from the EEA state in which you reside.
Scenario 6: If you are a member of the family of a person receiving a pension from one state and you receive a pension from a different state, your independent right to benefits in kind takes priority over the rights you have as a member of their family.76 Therefore, the state that pays your pension is the state from which you may be entitled to sickness benefits, unless you are entitled to a sickness benefit from the EEA state in which you reside.
To check the sickness benefits payable by EEA states, search online for ‘European Commission your rights country by country’.
Who is a member of the family for sickness benefits in kind
Under the main co-ordination rules, the definition of ‘member of the family’ for sickness benefits in kind is slightly different to the general definition (see here). The difference is highlighted below in italics.
You are a ‘member of the family’ of a person covered by the main co-ordination rules for the purpose of sickness benefits in kind, if:76
- you are a person defined or recognised as a member of the family, or designated as a member of the household, by the legislation under which benefits are provided of the member state in which you reside; or
- the legislation under which benefits are provided does not make a distinction between the members of the family and other people to whom it applies, and you are the covered person’s spouse or child who is either under the age of majority or older but dependent on the person covered.
If, under the legislation in either bullet point above, you are only considered to be a member of the family or member of the household if you are living in the same household as the person, this condition is considered to be satisfied if you are mainly dependent on them.
If you have a right to benefits in kind as a member of the family, as well as an independent right to benefits in kind, your independent right takes priority unless this is only based on residence.77 See Scenarios 5 and 6.
Checklist to determine if the UK is your competent state for sickness benefits
If you are claiming AA, PADP, the care component of DLA, CDP or SADLA, the daily living component of PIP or ADP, CA or CSP, check the following.
Is the UK the competent state?
1. Check whether the rules on competent state actually apply to you. These rules can only apply if you are covered by either the UK–Ireland Convention (see here) or the main co-ordination rules. Note that the latter can only apply if you are covered by either the Withdrawal Agreement protections (see here) or you are both covered by the partial Withdrawal Agreement protections and relying on the main co-ordination rules to either satisfy or disapply the past presence test (see here).
2. Are you employed or self-employed in the UK? Undertaking activity as an employed or self-employed person in the UK means the UK is the competent state for paying sickness benefits. Note: your earnings do not need to exceed the threshold at which you are liable to pay national insurance (NI) contributions. See here.
3. Are you (or a member of your family) receiving a pension from an EEA state (Ireland, if you are covered by the UK–Ireland Convention)? Check whether it is a state payment classed as a pension (private and occupational pensions are not classed as pensions). See here for the meaning of ‘pension’.
3. If you (or a member of your family) are receiving a pension from an EEA state (Ireland, if you are covered by the UK–Ireland Convention) and you reside in the UK, do, or could, you receive a pension from the UK? If you receive a pension from the UK, the UK is responsible for the cost of your sickness benefits in kind (ie, NHS treatment) and so is the competent state for paying sickness benefits (see Scenario 3 on here).
4. If you (or a member of your family) are receiving a pension from an EEA state, and you reside in the UK and are not entitled to a pension from the UK, the UK is the competent state on the basis of residence and this is not affected by receipt of the pension for periods since 5 December 2024, following the Upper Tribunal decision of that date (see Scenario 1 on here) (since 27 September 2023 in Northern Ireland – see here). If you are only covered by the UK–Ireland Convention and you receive a pension from Ireland, you reside in the UK and are not entitled to a pension from the UK, and your claim for a UK sickness benefit is refused on the basis the UK is not your competent state, challenge the decision, get advice and ask your adviser to contact CPAG to argue the reasoning of the recent caselaw also applies to the convention.
5. If you reside in an EEA state and receive a UK pension, the UK is the competent state to pay your sickness benefits, if you are not entitled to sickness benefits in your state of residence (see Scenario 2 on here). This applies even if a member of your family receives a pension from an EEA state (see Scenario 6). However, the UK will not be your competent state if you also receive a pension from the EEA state in which you reside and you are entitled to a sickness benefit from that state (see Scenario 3).
7. If you reside in the UK, do not receive a pension, and a member of your family is insured (eg, due to them working) in an EEA state, the UK is your competent state and this is not affected by the member of your family working in an EEA state for periods since 21 April 2023, following the Court of Appeal decision of that date (see here).
6. If the DWP has decided that the UK is not the competent state, your claim should not simply be refused - see here.
7. If your claim is refused, or your award terminated, challenge the decision, get advice and ask your adviser to contact CPAG.
References
- 1
Art 11 EU Reg 883/04; Art 9 UK-IC; Art SSC10 UK-EUP; Art 13 UK-EFTAC
- 2
Art 1(s) EU Reg 883/04; Art SSC1(i) UK-EUP; Art 1(k) UK-EFTAC
- 3
Art 1(q) EU Reg 883/04; Art SSC1(h) UK-EUP; Art 1(i) UK-EFTAC
- 4
Art 11 EU Reg 883/04; Art 9 UK-IC; Art SSC10 UK-EUP; Art 13 UK-EFTAC
- 5
Art 65 EU Reg 883/04; Art 22 UK-IC
- 6
Art 11(3)(e) EU Reg 883/04; Art 9(4)(e) UK-IC; Art SSC10(3)(c) UK-EUP; Art 13(3)(d) UK-EFTAC
- 7
JS v SSWP [2019] UKUT 239 (AAC); ADM Memo 1/20 and DMG Memo 3/20
- 8
Art 11(2) EU Reg 883/04; Art 9(2) and (3) UK-IC; Art SSC10(2) UK-EUP; Art 13(2) UK-EFTAC
- 9
Art 13 EU Reg 883/04; Art SSC12 and Annex SSC-7, Art SSCI.13(1)-(4) UK-EUP; Art 15 and Annex 1, Art 13(11) and (12) UK-EFTAC
- 10
Art 12 EU Reg 883/04; Art 10 UK-IC
- 11
Art SSC 11 and Annex SSC7, Art SSCI.13(1)-(4) UK-EUP; Art 14 and Annex 1, Art 13(1)-(4) UK-EFTAC
- 12
AR v HMRC (CHB) [2014] UKUT 553 (AAC); HB v HMRC (CHB) [2014] UKUT 554 (AAC), paras 37-39
- 13
Main co-ordination rules Arts 67, 68 and 81 EU Reg 883/04; Arts 2, 45 and 60 EU Reg 987/2009; SSWP v AK (AA) [2015] UKUT 110 (AAC), reported as [2015] AACR 27; MGL v SSWP (ESA) [2018] UKUT 352 (AAC)
UK-IC Art 60
UK-EUP Art SSC62
UK-EFTAC Art 65
- 14
Art 1(j) EU Reg 883/04; Art 1(1) UK-IC; Art SSC1(aa) UK-EUP; Art 1(jj) UK-EFTAC
- 15
Art 30(5) WA 2019; Art 29(5) UK-EFTA; Art 25(5) UK-SA
- 16
Art 1(1) UK-IC
- 17
Art 11 EU Reg 987/2009; Annex SSC-7, Art SSCI.10 UK-EUP; Annex 1, Art 10 UK-EFTAC
- 18
Art 11(2) EU Reg 987/09; Annex SSC-7, Art SSCI.10(3) UK-EUP; Annex 1, Art 10(2) UK-EFTAC
- 19
Arts 11-16 EU Reg 883/04; Arts 9-13 UK-IC; Arts SSC10-13 UK-EUP; Arts 13-18 UK-EFTAC
- 20
See, for example, SSWP v MC (DLA) [2019] UKUT 84 (AAC) and DMG Memo 6/24, paras 18-20, and ADM Memo 7/24, paras 18-20
- 21
Carrington v HMRC and SSWP [2021] EWCA Civ 1724
- 22
See, for example, Kuusijärvi v Riksförsäkringsverket, C-275/96 [1998]; AR v HMRC (CHB) [2014] UKUT 553 (AAC); HB v HMRC (CHB) [2014] UKUT 554 (AAC); SSWP v Tolley, C-430/15 [2017]; SSWP v MC (DLA) [2019] UKUT 84 (AAC); KR v SSWP (DLA) [2019] UKUT 85 (AAC), reported as [2019] AACR 22
- 23
Harrington v SSWP [2023] EWCA Civ 433; DMG Memo 6/24, paras 18-20, and ADM Memo 7/24, paras 18-20
- 25
KR v SSWP (DLA) [2019] UKUT 85 (AAC), reported as [2019] AACR 22, paras 18-24
- 26
Main rules Art 81 EU Reg 883/2004; Art 2 EU Reg 987/2009; SSWP v AK (AA) [2015] UKUT 110 (AAC), reported as [2015] AACR 27; see also MGL v SSWP (ESA) [2018] UKUT 352 (AAC); Vol 2 Ch 7 Part 2 Appendix 4 DMG; Ch C2 Appendix 2 ADM
UK-IC Art 60 UK-EUP Art SSC62
UK-EFTAC Art 65
- 27
Art 40(2) UK-IC
- 28
Art 6(2) EU Reg 987/2009; Art 63(2) UK-IC; Annex SSC-7, Art SSCI.6 UK-EUP; Annex 1, Art 6 UK-EFTAC; SSWP v HR (AA) [2014] UKUT 571 (AAC), reported as [2015] AACR 26; SSWP v SO [2019] UKUT 55 (AAC)
- 29
Art 6(3) EU Reg 987/2009; Annex SSC-7, Art SSCI.6(3) UK-EUP
- 30
Art 62 UK-IC
- 31
Arts 6(4)-(5) and 73 EU Reg 987/2009; Art 63(5) UK-IC; Annex SSC7, Arts SSCI.6(5) and SSCI 57 UK-EUP; Annex 1, Arts 6(5) and 54-68 UK-EFTAC
- 32
SSWP v AK (AA) [2015] UKUT 110 (AAC), reported as [2015] AACR 27, paras 29-30
- 33
SSWP v Fileccia [2017] EWCA Civ 1907, paras 45 and 46; see also SSWP v HR (AA) [2014] UKUT 571 (AAC), reported as [2015] AACR 26, paras 16-19; Ch C2 Appendix 2 para 5 ADM; Vol 2 Ch7 Pt 2 Appendix 4 para 5 DMG
- 34
AH v SSWP [2020] UKUT 53 (AAC), paras 7-19; Harrington v SSWP [2023] EWCA Civ 433, paras 21,24,32 and 51; DMG Memo 6/24, paras 5 and 7; ADM Memo 7/24, paras 5 and 7
- 35
AA s65(7) SSCBA 1992
PADP Regs 13(c)(ii), 14(2)(a)(ii) and 16 DAOP(S) Regs
ADP Regs 19(c)(ii), 20(2)(a)(ii) and 20A DAWAP(S) Regs DLA s72(7B) SSCBA 1992 PIP s84 WRA 2012 CA s70(4A) SSCBA 1992
CDP Regs 8(c)(ii) 9(2)(a)(i) and 9A DACYP(S) Regs
SADLA Regs 14(c)(ii), 15(2)(a)(ii) and 16 DA(SADLA) Regs
CSP Regs 10 and 11 CA(CSP)(S) Regs
YCG Reg 8(3)-(10) CA(YCG)(S) Regs
- 36
Art 3 UK-IC
- 37
ADP Reg 15(3)(c) DAWAP(S) Regs
PADP Reg 9(3)(c)(ii) DAOP(S) Regs
SADLA Reg 10(3)(c)(ii) DA(SADLA) Regs
CDP Reg 5(4) DACYP(S) Regs
CSP Reg 6(3)-(4) CA(CSP)(S) Regs
YCG Reg 8(3) and (6) CA(YCG)(S) Regs
- 38
SSWP v AH [2016] UKUT 148 (AAC); linked cases: JGv SSWP [2019] UKUT 83 (AAC), paras 41-43; Konevodv SSWP [2020] EWCA Civ 809, paras 52-54
- 39
Art 11(3)(a) EU Reg 883/04; JS v SSWP [2019] UKUT 239 (AAC); Vol 2 Ch 7 Part 2 Appendix, note to para 22 DMG; Ch 2 Appendix 1, note to para 22 ADM; ADM Memo 1/20; DMG Memo 3/20
- 40
Art 11(3)(e) EU Reg 883/04; Art 9(4)(e) UK-IC
- 41
DMG Memo 16/20, para 37; ADM Memo 17/20, para 38
- 42
DMG Memo 6/24, para 22; ADM Memo 7/24, para 22
- 43
Art 21(1) EU Reg 883/04
- 44
AH v SSWP [2020] UKUT 53 (AAC)
- 45
Harrington v SSWP [2023] EWCA Civ 433, especially paras 44 and 60 - the SSWP did not appeal to the SC
- 46
SE v SSWP [2024] UKUT 405 (AAC) - the DWP did not pursue its appeal
- 47
SSWP v KLQ [2026] UKUT 156 (AAC)
- 48
DMG Memo 3/26; ADM Memo 8/26
- 49
SP v DfCNI (PIP) [2023] NICom 23 and IP v DfCNI (AA) [2023] NICom 27
- 50
SE v SSWP [2024] UKUT 405 (AAC), para 106
- 51
DCNI DMG Memo Vol 2/111; DCNI ADM Memo 5/26
- 52
DMG Memo 3/26, paras 18-25; ADM Memo 8/26, paras 16-23; DCNI DMG Memo Vol 2/111, paras 18-26; DCNI ADM Memo 5/26, paras 16-24
- 53
Art 20 UK-IC; partially summarised in DMG Memo 7/24, para 9
- 54
Art 1(w) EU Reg 883/04
- 55
JS v SSWP (DLA) [2012] AACR 7, para 14; KS v SSWP (DLA) [2014] UKUT 19 (AAC), para 81; both in relation to EU Reg 1408/71
- 56
LD v SSWP [2017] UKUT 65 (AAC) - PTA to CA refused
- 57
SSWP v SO [2019] UKUT 55 (AAC), paras 11-12
- 58
Perry v Chief Adjudication Officer [1998]; EC v SSWP (SPC) [2010] UKUT 95 (AAC), para 40
- 59
IG v SSWP [2016] UKUT 176 (AAC), reported as [2016] AACR 41, para 25; see also KS v SSWP [2018] UKUT 121 (AAC), para 6
- 60
Skalka v Sozialversicherungsanstalt der Gewerblichen Wirtschaft, C-160/02 [2004]; Naranjo v CRAM Nord-Picardie, C-265/05 [2007]
- 61
SSWP v SO [2019] UKUT 55 (AAC); SSWP v TG (DLA) [2019] UKUT 86 (AAC), para 17; GK v SSWP (CA) [2019] UKUT 87 (AAC), para 16
- 62
KR v SSWP (DLA) [2019] UKUT 85 (AAC), reported as [2019] AACR 22, paras 6 and 13-17
- 63
para C2124 ADM; Vol 2 Ch 7 Part 2 para 071771 DMG; ADM Memo 17/20, para 13 and para 20 examples 1 and 2; DMG Memo 16/20, para 13
- 64
SP v DfCNI (PIP) [2023] NICom 23, paras 33-36 and 61
- 66
SSWP v SO [2019] UKUT 55 (AAC), para 10
- 65
Arts 25 and 29 EU Reg 883/04
- 67
SE v SSWP [2024] UKUT 405 (AAC)
- 68
See example of Olivia in DMG Memo 3/26 and ADM Memo 8/26; SSWP v KLQ [2026] UKUT 156 (AAC)
- 69
DMG Memo 3/26, paras 9-13; ADM Memo 8/26, paras 9-13
- 70
DMG Memo 11/22, para 16; ADM Memo 15/22, para 16
- 71
Examples of Rose and Sam in DMG Memo 3/26 and ADM Memo 8/26 and of Theo in ’Competent State’ in ADP SSS DMG (R and P)
- 72
Art 23 EU Reg 883/04; SSWP v HR (AA) [2013] UKUT 66 (AAC); SL v SSWP (DLA) [2014] UKUT 108 (AAC)
- 73
ADM Memo 17/20, para 13 and para 24 examples 1 and 2; DMG Memo 16/20, para 13 and para 24 examples 1 and 2; C2124 ADM; Ch 7, Part 2 para 071771 DMG
- 74
Arts 24(2)(b) and 25 EU Reg 883/04; Helder and Farrington v College voor Zorgverzekeringen, C-321/12 [2013]; see also example of Jill in ’Competent State’ in PADP SSS DMG (R and P)
- 75
Art 26 EU Reg 883/04
- 76
Art 1(i)(1) and (ii), (2) and (3) EU Reg 883/04
- 77
Art 32(1) EU Reg 883/04
Equal treatment of people
If you are covered by any of the sets of co-ordination rules, you are entitled to the same benefits under the legislation of the competent state (see here) as a national of that state.1 Equal treatment is one of the fundamental rights of EU law,2 and the principle of non-discrimination prohibits discrimination based on your nationality. Both direct discrimination and, unless justified as proportionate and pursuing a legitimate aim, indirect discrimination are prohibited.
Direct discrimination arises when one person is treated less favourably than another in the same situation. Indirect discrimination arises when apparently neutral and non-discriminatory rules have, in practice, a greater adverse impact on some people than others – eg, non-nationals of the competent state over nationals of the competent state. For example, the four-week restriction on housing benefit for claimants who go abroad appears to apply equally to all claimants. However, in a recent Upper Tribunal case, it was accepted by the local authority and the DWP that this restriction discriminates against EEA national workers in the UK compared to British workers (who are more likely to be within Great Britain, during an absence from their home, and therefore subject to a 13-week restriction). It was held that this indirect discrimination was not justified. Therefore, the restriction was unlawful under EU law3 and had to be disapplied for that Czech worker who was abroad in 2020 for less than 13 weeks visiting family in the Czech Republic.4 A separate example of indirect discrimination is the habitual residence test for means-tested benefits which appeared, when the UK was a member of the EU, to apply equally to all EEA nationals. However, British and Irish citizens always have a right to reside in the common travel area (the UK, Ireland, Channel Islands and the Isle of Man) and therefore satisfy the right to reside requirement within the test, whereas other EEA nationals only satisfy it in certain circumstances. Therefore, the test is indirectly discriminatory. However, the Supreme Court decided in a case concerning PC that this discrimination is justified and, therefore, legal.5 Similarly, the CJEU held that the right to reside test for child benefit (and child tax credit) was not directly discriminatory and, although indirectly discriminatory, this was justified.6 Although the Northern Ireland Chief Commissioner found that the right to reside test for child benefit was directly and indirectly discriminatory, that decision was overturned by the Court of Appeal in Northern Ireland.7
There may be a separate argument that the exclusion of pre-settled status as a qualifying right to reside for child benefit amounts to unlawful unequal treatment under the main EU co-ordination rules following a more recent CJEU case on a German family benefit.8 If you have pre-settled status and your child benefit has been refused or terminated, challenge the decision, get advice and ask your adviser to contact CPAG to assist with equal treatment arguments.
In 2021, the CJEU considered whether the exclusion from universal credit (UC) of EU nationals who have been granted pre-settled status under the EU Settlement Scheme (EUSS), and who have no other right to reside, was unlawfully discriminatory. The CJEU held that this exclusion was not discriminatory in the case of an EU citizen who claimed UC before the end of the transition period.9 The CJEU had considered whether the regulations were contrary to the equal treatment provisions of the EU Directive 2004/38,10 rather than contrary to the equal treatment provisions of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU (TFEU),11 but found that as the claimant did not have a right to reside under that Directive, she could not rely on its equal treatment provisions.
In an earlier separate case, on the same question, the Court of Appeal had held that the equal treatment provisions of the TFEU did apply and meant the exclusion of pre-settled status was direct discrimination on nationality grounds and therefore unlawful.12 That Court of Appeal judgment overturned the decision of the High Court that this exclusion was only indirect discrimination and was lawful because it was justified.13 However, the DWP appealed the Court of Appeal’s decision to the Supreme Court, which allowed the appeal, as the question was held to have already been answered definitively by the CJEU.14
An argument that the equal treatment provisions of the Withdrawal Agreement15 require the exclusion of pre-settled status to be disapplied was rejected, in a housing case, by the Court of Appeal and permission to appeal to the Supreme Court was refused.16 This caselaw applies equally to means-tested benefits and child benefit, and will be applied in any cases, including at least one UC Upper Tribunal appeal, that have been ‘stayed’ (not decided; ‘sisted’ in Scotland) pending the outcome of the housing case.17
The argument required that the application of the equal treatment provisions under the Withdrawal Agreements be distinguished from those of the EU Directive 2004/38, which the CJEU previously held did not apply unless the claimant with pre-settled status also had a right to reside under that Directive (see above), but this was rejected by the Court of Appeal. In an earlier housing case, the county court had held that the declaratory scheme of rights under EU Directive 2004/38 was distinguishable from the constitutive scheme of the EUSS, and that the right to equal treatment under the Withdrawal Agreement is not conditional on having a free movement right to reside. Consequently, the county court held that the equal treatment provisions of the Withdrawal Agreement required that the exclusion of pre-settled status be disapplied (the local authority did not appeal against this decision).18 A narrower form of this argument was also accepted by the county court in a separate housing case.19
For information about other arguments that may apply to those with pre-settled status seeking to claim benefits that require a right to reside, see here.
References
- 1
Art 4 EU Reg 883/04; Art 4 UK-IC; Art SSC5 UK-EUP; Art 8 UK-EFTAC
- 2
Art 18 TFEU; Art 24 EU Dir 2004/38; Art 7 EU Reg 492/2011; Arts 12 and 23 WA 2019; Arts 11 and 22 UK-EFTA; Art 7 UK-SA
- 3
Arts 7 and 9 EU Reg 492/2011
- 4
Michaela Kuzelova v LB Barnet and SSWP [2026] UKUT 272 (AAC)
- 5
Patmalniece v SSWP [2011] UKSC 11
- 6
European Commission v UK, C-308/14 [2016]
- 7
Commissioners for HMRC v Aiga Spiridonova, 13/115948
- 8
S v Familienkasse Niedersachsen-Bremen der Bundesagentur für Arbeit C-411/20 [2022]; Art 4 EU Reg 883/04; Art 24 EU Dir 2004/38
- 9
CG v Department for Communities NI, C-709/20 [2021]; see also AG Opinion (June 2021)
- 10
Art 24 EU Dir 2004/38
- 11
Art 18 TFEU
- 12
Fratila and Tanase v SSWP [2020] EWCA Civ 1741
- 13
Fratila and Tanase v SSWP [2020] EWHC 998 (Admin)
- 14
Fratila and Tanase v SSWP [2021] UKSC 53
- 15
Arts 12 and 23 WA 2019
- 16
Fertre v Vale of White Horse DC [2025] EWCA Civ 1057. Permission refused 23 March 2026: UKSC/2026/0006
- 17
GN v SSWP UA-2023-001153-USTA
- 18
Hynek v LB Islington (Aire Centre and The 3Million intervening), claim ref K40CL206, paras 33-79
- 19
C v Oldham Council (Aire Centre and The 3Million intervening) [2024] EWCC 1
Equal treatment of facts and events
Each of the sets of co-ordination rules provide for the ‘equal treatment of benefits, income, facts or events’.1 This provision is sometimes referred to as the ‘principle of the assimilation of facts’. This principle is designed to ensure that if the competent state regards the receipt of a particular benefit or income, or the occurrence of certain facts or events, as producing certain legal effects, it should regard the receipt of an equivalent benefit or income from another member state, or the occurrence of particular facts or events in another member state, as producing the same effect. For example, if one state has determined that a person has had an industrial accident, that fact must be accepted, by the competent state, for the purpose of awarding benefit.
A benefit paid by a member state is equivalent to a benefit paid by another member state if they are comparable, taking account of the aim of each benefit and the legislation under which they are established. Receipt of a Polish benefit paid on the basis that the claimant was incapable of independent living was accepted in one Upper Tribunal case as equivalent to the middle or higher rate of DLA care component and therefore entitled the claimant’s carer to CA, and in a separate case, as equivalent to AA and therefore entitled the claimant to a severe disability addition within her PC.2
The Upper Tribunal held that this principle did not apply to the effects of receiving a benefit on working tax credit (WTC) because WTC was not a benefit covered by the main co-ordination rules. However, because other EU regulations required workers from EEA states to have the same ‘social advantages’ as national workers,3 the regulations on entitlement to the childcare element had to be interpreted so as to accept a Dutch invalidity benefit as evidence of a claimant’s incapacity.4 Following this judgment, the WTC regulations were amended to include any benefit paid by an EEA state that is substantially similar to any of the UK benefits listed as evidence of incapacity.5
Note: the UC regulations treat a benefit paid by another state in the same way as a UK benefit that counts as unearned income, if the foreign benefit is ‘analogous to’ the UK benefit or is a state retirement pension.6 Similarly, the PC regulations treat as income a benefit paid by another state if it is ‘similar to’ a UK benefit that counts as income, or is a state retirement pension.7
There are exceptions to the general principle of the assimilation of facts, some of which are set out in the co-ordination rules, and others arise as a result of a conflict between this principle and other principles of the co-ordination rules. For example, the assimilation of facts cannot render another member state competent.8 The competent state should first be determined (see here) and then that state should assimilate the facts for the purposes of its own legislation.
The assimilation principle should also not interfere with the principle of aggregation (see below).9 So, the competent state should count periods of insurance in another EEA state (under the aggregation principle) without needing to address the question of whether they count as periods of insurance for the assimilation principle to apply. If it counts as a period of insurance under the legislation of the state in which it took place, that period can be aggregated.
References
- 1
Art 5 EU Reg 883/04; Art 5 UK-IC; Art SSC6 UK-EUP; Art 9 UK-EFTAC
- 2
Knauer v Landeshauptmann von Vorarlberg, C-453/14 [2016]; CG/1346/2018; HT v SSWP [2020] UKUT 57 (AAC); Vol 10 Ch 60 para 60033 point 8 DMG (also referred to by para F6013 ADM)
- 3
Art 7(1) and (2) EU Reg 492/11
- 4
AS v HMRC [2017] UKUT 361 (AAC), reported as [2018] AACR 14
- 5
Reg 13(6)(K) WTC(EMR) Regs
- 6
Reg 66(1)(c) and (da) and (2)(a) UC Regs; for example, see LR v SSWP (UC) [2022] UKUT 65 (AAC); see also reg 83(2)(d) UC Regs
- 7
Reg 15(2) SPC Regs
- 8
Recital 11 EU Reg 883/04
- 9
Recital 10 EU Reg 883/04
Aggregation
The principle of aggregation for the purpose of acquiring and calculating entitlement to benefits is a key co-ordinating principle in each of the sets of co-ordination rules.1 The aim of this principle is to remove disadvantages that arise when claiming benefit after moving from one member state to another.
’Aggregation’ means adding together periods of insurance (eg, periods in which you have paid NI contributions in the UK), residence or employment/self-employment completed under the legislation of one or more member states to satisfy the conditions of entitlement for a benefit. For example, if you have not paid sufficient NI contributions in the UK, you can rely on periods of insurance in one or more other member states to satisfy the UK contribution rules for ESA.
The competent institution for the benefit you are claiming must contact the competent institutions in the other relevant states to determine the periods completed under their legislation.2
What constitutes a period of residence, employment or insurance is determined by the legislation of the state in which it took place.3
Note: to rely on the main co-ordination rules, you need to be covered by the Withdrawal Agreement protections (see here) (but see also retirement pensions below). However, if you are not, or no longer, covered by these, you can use the aggregation principle of the main co-ordination rules if you are covered by the partial Withdrawal Agreement protections (see here). This is particularly important if you need to rely on aggregating past periods of residence to satisfy the past presence test for the disability and carers’ benefits, because the UK–EU Protocol and UK–EFTA Convention do not cover these benefits.
Example
Sancha is a Portuguese national who had been working in the UK for several years and was granted settled status in 2021. In July 2023, she moved to take up employment in Portugal. She left her job in Portugal one month ago and moved back to the UK. She worked in the UK for two weeks before being made redundant. Sancha is expecting a baby in two months and claims maternity allowance (MA). She can be entitled to MA because the UK is her competent state, and she can add her period of employment in Portugal to her employment in the UK to satisfy the employment condition of having worked for 26 out of the last 66 weeks.
Note: as Sancha was out of the UK for less than five years, and therefore continues to have settled status, she should be accepted as having Withdrawal Agreement protections, which enable her to use the main co-ordination rules (that she would be covered by – see here). However, if the DWP decides she only has partial Withdrawal Agreement protections, this still enables her to use the aggregation principle of the main co-ordination rules. If, when Sancha left her job in Portugal and arrived in the UK a month ago, it was her first time in the UK (and if she was not joining any EEA national family members in the UK), the main co-ordination rules would not apply to her, but she would be covered by the UK–EU Protocol (see here) and could use the aggregation principle under these rules (but whether she had a right to work would depend on her immigration status).
For retirement pensions:
- you claim in the country where you are living (or where you last worked if that was not where you are living), but your total pension may be made up of pensions paid by more than one state. If you are claiming in the UK, you should contact the International Pension Centre (see gov.uk/international-pension-centre) and see here. Note that differing retirement ages can affect when a state pays its proportion of your pension;
- to be entitled to a UK retirement pension, note that the provisions of the main co-ordination rules on aggregation and uprating were saved and continue to apply (see here).4
Disability and carers’ benefits
The main co-ordination rules provide for residence in a member state to be aggregated with presence in Great Britain to satisfy the past presence test for AA, CA, PIP or DLA, or with presence in the common travel area to satisfy the past presence test for ADP, PADP, SADLA, CDP or CSP (see here).5
Note:
- The Upper Tribunal has held that ‘mere residence’ in an EEA country cannot be aggregated under the main co-ordination rules for the purpose of satisfying the past presence test in disability and carers’ benefits. Although in these cases it was not necessary to decide what qualities the residence must have in order to count, it was suggested that insurance-based, or contribution-based, residence would count.6 The appeal against this part of the judgment was dropped when the appeal was heard by the Court of Appeal.7 In practice, the benefit authorities generally accept evidence of your having worked in an EEA state as evidence that the residence was not mere residence.
- If you may not be able to aggregate your residence in an EEA state due to its being mere residence, or in addition to satisfying the past presence test through aggregation, always check whether the test can be disapplied due to your being covered by the main co-ordination rules (see here and example on here).
- You can rely on the aggregation principle of the main co-ordination rules if you are covered by the Withdrawal Agreement protections (see here) or if these do not, or no longer, apply, the partial Withdrawal Agreement protections (see here).8 However, if you can potentially receive benefit as a result of aggregating past periods of residence, the rules on the competent state for sickness benefits apply to your claim for AA, PADP, CA, CSP, the daily living component of PIP or ADP and the care component of DLA, SADLA or CDP (see here).
The UK–Ireland Convention states that, if the UK is your competent state for these benefits, you can be entitled to AA, DLA care component, PIP daily living component and CA while resident in Ireland. However, when determining this entitlement, only periods of residence in Ireland during which you were insured can count towards the past presence requirement.9 Note: because PADP, SADLA, ADP, CDP and CSP require past presence in the common travel area, which includes Ireland, reliance on aggregation of residence in Ireland under the UK–Ireland Convention is not necessary.
The UK–EU Protocol and UK–EFTA Convention do not cover these disability and carers’ benefits (see here).10
Note: the UK–Gibraltar Agreement (see here) provides for you to be entitled to AA, PADP, CA, CSP, the daily living component of PIP or ADP and the care component of DLA, SADLA or CDP while resident in Gibraltar, if the UK is your competent state for these benefits. However, when determining this entitlement, only periods of residence in Gibraltar during which you were insured can count towards the past presence requirement.11
Unemployment benefits
When determining entitlement to unemployment benefits, your periods of insurance (if entitlement depends on insurance) or employment/self-employment (if entitlement depends on this) completed in all member states are only aggregated if you were last insured or you last worked (whichever is required) under the legislation of the state from which you are claiming benefit.12
Example
Tomasz is a Polish national. He worked and was insured in Poland for four years, until he became unemployed in January 2025. He decided to join his Polish wife, who has been working in the UK since 2019 and has settled status. Tomasz obtained pre-settled status and came to the UK in February 2025. He began work on his arrival, but a year later he was made redundant. In February 2026 he claimed jobseeker’s allowance (JSA). He could aggregate the weeks in which he paid NI contributions in the UK during the last complete tax year (6 April 2024 to 5 April 2025) with those weeks in which he was insured in Poland and thereby satisfy the contribution requirements of JSA. Note that if he had claimed JSA when he arrived in February 2025, he would not have been able to use his insurance contributions paid in Poland.
However, under the main co-ordination rules and the UK–Ireland Convention, this additional condition does not apply if, during your last period of employment or self-employment, you resided in a state other than your competent state. In this case, if you claim an unemployment benefit in the state in which you continue to reside (or have returned to), you can aggregate periods of insurance or employment or self-employment in order to be entitled to that benefit.13
Example
Monique is a Belgian national who was employed in the UK for six years until 2023. She obtained settled status and then moved to France where she worked until February 2025. Monique then got a job in Germany that she could do while working from home, so she moved back to the UK. In February 2026, she was made redundant and immediately claimed JSA. Monique was entitled to this because she could aggregate the contributions paid in both Germany and France.
References
- 1
Art 6 EU Reg 883/04; see also Annex XI UK entry, para 2, and Art 48 TFEU; Art 6 UK-IC; Art SSC7 UK-EUP; Art 10 UK-EFTAC
- 2
Art 12 EU Reg 987/09; PB v SSWP (DLA) [2016] UKUT 280 (AAC), para 10, second ground of appeal; Annex SSC-7, Art SSCI 11 UK-EUP; Annex 1, Art 11 UK-EFTAC
- 3
Arts 1(t)(u) and (v) and 6 EU Reg 883/04; Decision H6 of 16 December 2010 of the Administrative Commission for the Coordination of Social Security Systems [2011] OJ C-45/04; Art 6(2) UK-IC; Art SSC7 UK-EUP; Art 10 UK-EFTAC
- 4
Regs 5 and 9 SSC(RRDEL) Regs
- 5
Art 6 and Annex XI UK entry para 2 EU Reg 883/04; SSWP v MM and BK v SSWP [2016] UKUT 547 (AAC), reported as [2019] AACR 21, para 25
- 6
SSWP v MM and BK v SSWP [2016] UKUT 547 (AAC), reported as [2019] AACR 21, paras 18-27 and 35
- 7
Kavanagh and Another v SSWP [2019] EWCA Civ 272
- 8
Art 32 WA 2019; Art 31 UK-EFTA; Art 26a UK-SA; see also DWPWAG, Ch 1 paras 43-52
- 9
Arts 6 and 19 UK-IC
- 10
Art SSC3(4)(a) and (d), and Annex SSC-1, Part 1(i)(c) and (d), and Part 2(i) UK-EUP; Art 6(5)(a) and (d), and Annex 2, Parts 1 and 2 UK-EFTAC
- 11
Arts 6 and 19 UK-GA
- 12
Art 61 EU Reg 883/04; see, for example, ONEM v M and M v ONEM, C-284/15 [2015]; Art 21(1) and (2) UK-IC; Art SSC56 UK-EUP; Art 58 UK-EFTAC
- 13
Arts 61(2) and 65(2) and (5)(a) EU Reg 883/04; Arts 21(2) and 22(4)(a) UK-IC; see also Decision U2 of 12 June 2009 of the Administrative Commission for the Coordination of Social Security Systems [2012] OJ C-106/12
Exporting benefits
Each set of co-ordination rules allows you to export certain social security benefits from one member state to another if you cease to be resident in the state in which your entitlement arose.
This means that certain benefits may not be reduced, modified, suspended, withdrawn or confiscated just because you go to live in a different member state.1 The rules for exporting vary according to the benefit concerned: some are fully exportable, some may be exportable temporarily and some are not exportable at all. The rules also vary between the different sets of co-ordination rules, with the main co-ordination rules being the most generous.
Check the individual benefit rules in Chapter 15 to see whether a benefit can be exported under the rules that apply to you. If it can, you should contact the office that pays your benefit, well in advance if possible, so arrangements can be made to pay you in the state you are going to. The rules covering periodic reassessments still apply – so, for example, if you export ESA, the DWP continues to assess your limited capability for work and your limited capability for work-related activity. However, any checks and medicals take place in the state in which you are living, with reports then sent to the DWP.2
Under the main co-ordination rules, and the UK–Ireland Convention, all UK benefits categorised as social security benefits are exportable, provided the UK remains the competent state for the payment of that benefit (see here). However, the UK–EU Protocol and the UK–EFTA Convention exclude invalidity and unemployment benefits from export provisions and do not cover disability and carers’ benefits (classed as long-term care benefits or special non-contributory benefits) or family benefits.3 See here for how UK benefits are categorised.
The following benefits can be exported indefinitely:
- old age benefits;
- survivor’s benefits;
- pensions for accidents at work or occupational diseases;
- (not under the UK–EU Protocol or UK–EFTA Convention) invalidity benefits;
- (not under the UK–EU Protocol or UK–EFTA Convention) family benefits (see here);
- death grants.
The following benefits can be exported for a limited period or subject to certain restrictions:
- (not under the UK–EU Protocol or UK–EFTA Convention) unemployment benefits;
- sickness, maternity and paternity benefits (although, in most cases, these benefits are exportable in a similar way to the fully exportable benefits).
Special non-contributory benefits (see here) cannot be exported under any of the sets of co-ordination rules. Either the rules do not cover these benefits or, under the main co-ordination rules, they are paid only in the state in which you are resident (see here).4
References
- 1
Art 7 EU Reg 883/04; Art 7 UK-IC; Art SSC8 UK-EUP; Art 11 UK-EFTAC
- 2
Arts 5, 46 and 82 EU Reg 883/04; Arts 27, 46, 49 and 87 EU Reg 987/2009; Art 59(7) UK-IC; Art SSC63 UK-EUP; Art 66 UK-EFTAC
- 3
Arts SSC3(1) and (4) and SSC8 and Annex SSC1, Part 2 UK-EUP; Arts 6(1) and (5) and 11 and Annex 2 Part 2 UK-EFTAC
- 4
Art 70 EU Reg 883/04
Overlapping benefit rules
A general principle of each set of co-ordination rules is that you should not use one period of compulsory insurance to obtain more than one benefit derived from that period of insurance.1 In general, you are only insured in one member state for any one period, so you cannot use insurance from that one period to obtain entitlement to benefits of the same kind from more than one state. Usually, benefits are adjusted to ensure that either only one state (the competent state – see here) pays the benefit, taking into account periods of insurance in other member states, or the benefit is paid pro rata according to the lengths of the periods of insurance in different states.2
In certain cases, you may be paid both the full level of a UK benefit and a proportion of a benefit from another state, accrued as a result of having been insured in that state for a sufficient period. Under the main co-ordination rules, member states cannot apply provisions preventing their own benefits overlapping with those of other states if this would reduce what you would have received under national law from your periods of contributions in the first state alone.3
There are particular overlapping rules on specific categories of benefits (eg, old age and survivor’s benefits,4 and, under the main co-ordination rules and the UK–Ireland Convention, family benefits (see here)5) and the UK–Ireland Convention prevents entitlement to statutory payments by one state at the same time as sickness, invalidity, maternity or paternity benefits by the other state.6
References
- 1
Art 10 EU Reg 883/04; Arts 8 and 31-33 UK-IC; Arts SSC9 and SSC48-50 UK-EUP; Arts 12 and 52-54 UK-EFTAC
- 2
See, for example, JMcG v (1) SSWP, (2) HMRC [2018] UKUT 2 (AAC), paras 15 and 26-31
- 3
Teresa and Silvana Petroni v Office National des Pensions Pour Travailleurs Salariés (ONPTS), Bruxelles C-24/75 [1975]
- 4
Arts 53-55 EU Reg 883/04; Art 31 UK-IC; Art SSC48(3) UK-EUP; Art 52(3) UK-EFTAC
- 5
Art 68 EU Reg 883/04; Art 39 UK-IC
- 6
Arts 16 and 17 UK-IC
5. Employment and support allowance
To be entitled to employment and support allowance (ESA), you must be in Great Britain.1 The rules on when ESA can be paid during a temporary absence abroad are on here. There are no residence conditions for ESA (except for ESA in youth, which you would have to have first claimed before May 2012 and still be in the same period of limited capability for work – see here).
References
- 1
ss1(3)(d) and 18(4)(a) WRA 2007
EU co-ordination rules
If you are covered by any of the European Union (EU) co-ordination rules (see here) and the UK is your competent state (see here), you can, if necessary, rely on insurance contributions paid in one or more of the member states covered by the set of co-ordination rules you are relying on to entitle you to ESA in the UK (under the aggregation principle - see here).
If you are covered by any of the EU co-ordination rules and have moved to the UK from one of the member states covered by the set of co-ordination rules you are relying on, you may be able to continue to receive a sickness or (unless you are only covered by the UK–EU Protocol or the UK–EFTA Convention) an invalidity benefit from that state. This is referred to as ‘exporting’ the benefit (see here). You can continue to receive the benefit if that state remains your competent state for paying it (see here). These rules operate broadly as they do if you move abroad to a member state from the UK, except in reverse (see here).
Reciprocal and other international agreements
If you have lived and worked in a country with which the UK has a reciprocal agreement (see here), you may be able to rely on insurance contributions paid in that country towards your entitlement to ESA in the UK if the agreement covers you and covers ESA. Similarly, if you are covered by another type of international agreement between the EU and another country, you may be able to do the same (see here).
Most reciprocal agreements do not cover ESA (see here). However, the reciprocal agreement between Northern Ireland and Great Britain was extended to cover ESA from 6 April 2016. For details, including the policies if you moved between Northern Ireland and Great Britain while claiming ESA before this date, see here.
6. Industrial injuries benefits
Industrial injuries benefits are:
- industrial injuries disablement benefit;
- reduced earnings allowance;
- retirement allowance;
- constant attendance allowance;
- exceptionally severe disablement allowance.
To be entitled to any of these benefits, you must have been:
- in Great Britain when the accident at work happened;1 or
- engaged in Great Britain in the employment that caused the disease (even if you have also been engaged outside Great Britain in that employment);2 or
- paying UK national insurance contributions, either at class 1 rate or at class 2 rate as a volunteer development worker, when the accident at work happened or you contracted the disease. Benefit is not payable until you return to Great Britain.3
There are exceptions that mean you can still qualify for industrial injuries benefits in respect of an accident which happens, or a disease which is contracted, outside Great Britain while you are:4
- employed as a mariner or aircraft worker; or
- employed as an apprentice pilot on board a ship or vessel; or
- on board an aircraft on a test flight starting in Great Britain in the course of your employment.
In these cases, there are also more generous rules for defining when accidents arise ‘out of and in the course of’ your employment, and for meeting time limits under the benefit rules.5
References
EU co-ordination rules
If you are covered by any of the sets of European Union co-ordination rules (see here), you can, if necessary, rely on periods of employment and insurance contributions paid in member states covered by the set of co-ordination rules you are relying on. These periods can be used to help you qualify for industrial injuries benefits in the UK under the aggregation principle (see here).
Industrial injuries benefits are classed as ‘benefits for accidents at work and occupational diseases’ under these co-ordination rules (see here).
If you have an accident while travelling abroad in another member state, this can be deemed to have occurred in the state liable to pay benefits for accidents at work and occupational diseases. If one state determines that you have had an accident or contracted a disease, that should be accepted by the state liable to pay benefit in respect of that accident or disease. These outcomes are achieved under the principle of equal treatment of facts or events (see here).1
If you have worked in two or more member states in jobs that gave you a prescribed industrial disease, you get benefit from the state in which you last did work that, by its nature, is likely to cause the disease and which recognises that disease under its industrial injuries scheme. If you make your claim to the state that does not have responsibility under this rule, your claim and all supporting evidence must be forwarded to the relevant institution in the correct state without delay.2
Reciprocal agreements
The UK has reciprocal agreements with several countries that cover industrial injuries benefits. The agreements determine which country is responsible for determining and paying your entitlement, and if, and how, you can combine injuries or take account of new accidents or diseases.
For information on reciprocal agreements, see here. For a list of countries, see Appendix 5 and for specific information on industrial injuries benefits, see here.
7. Jobseeker’s allowance
To be entitled to jobseeker’s allowance (JSA), you must be in Great Britain.1 The rules on when JSA can be paid during a temporary absence abroad are covered on here. There are no residence conditions for JSA.
Note: looking for work abroad does not count towards satisfying the JSA requirement that you be actively seeking employment.2
EU co-ordination rules
If you are covered by any of the sets of European Union (EU) co-ordination rules (see here), you may be able to rely on insurance contributions paid in one or more of the member states to entitle you to JSA in the UK under the aggregation principle (see here). However, because it is an unemployment benefit, you can usually only aggregate your contributions if your most recent period of paying or being credited with contributions was in the UK.1 See here for details and an exception.
If you are covered by the main EU co-ordination rules, have been working in a European Economic Area (EEA) state and are coming to (or returning to) the UK to look for work, you may be able to obtain a U2 form before leaving, which authorises you to export your unemployment benefit from that EEA state. If you are covered by the UK–Ireland Convention and have been working in Ireland, you may be able to export your Irish unemployment benefit. In either case, you can continue receiving that state’s unemployment benefit for up to three months, if:2
- you were getting that unemployment benefit immediately before coming to the UK;
- you were registered as available for work for four weeks in the other state (or less, if the other state’s rules allow);
- you claim JSA within seven days of the last day you were registered in the other state; and
- you satisfy the relevant jobseeking requirements for JSA.
The three months can be extended to a maximum of six months if the state from which you are claiming the unemployment benefit agrees.3
You cannot export unemployment benefits under the UK–EU Protocol or the UK–EFTA Convention.4
For general information on exporting benefits, see here.
Reciprocal and other international agreements
If you have lived and worked in a country with which the UK has a reciprocal agreement, you may be able to count periods of insurance paid in that country towards your entitlement to JSA in the UK if the agreement covers you and that benefit. Similarly, if you are covered by another type of international agreement between the EU and another country, you may be able to do the same (see here).
For information on reciprocal agreements, see here. For a list of countries, see Appendix 5 and for specific information on unemployment benefits, see here.
8. Maternity allowance
In general, to be entitled to maternity allowance (MA), you must have been employed or self-employed in Great Britain.1 However, you can count weeks of employment abroad before you returned to Great Britain if, throughout your absence, you remained ordinarily resident in Great Britain and you paid, or would have been liable to pay were it not for a reciprocal agreement, class 1 national insurance contributions.2
There are no residence requirements for MA. However, in general, you are disqualified if you are absent from Great Britain.3 See here for when you can continue to be entitled during a temporary absence.
References
EU co-ordination rules
If you are covered by any of the sets of European Union (EU) co-ordination rules (see here) and the UK is your competent state (see here), you can, if necessary, rely on periods of employment or self-employment in one or more of the member states covered by the set of co-ordination rules you are relying on, to satisfy the employment and earnings conditions to qualify for MA in the UK, under the aggregation principle (see here).
If you are covered by any of the EU co-ordination rules and have moved to the UK from another member state, you may be able to continue receiving a maternity or paternity benefit from that other state if that state continues to be your competent state for paying that benefit (see here). This is referred to as ‘exporting’ the benefit (see here).
Reciprocal agreements
The UK has reciprocal agreements with several countries that cover maternity benefits. These may, for example, enable you to rely on periods of employment or self-employment in that country to satisfy the employment and earnings conditions to qualify for MA in the UK.
For more information on reciprocal agreements, see here. For a list of countries, see Appendix 5 and for specific information on maternity benefits, see here.
9. Retirement pensions
Retirement pensions, other than a category D retirement pension, do not have any residence or presence conditions. They can be paid without time limit, whether or not you are present in Great Britain. However, going abroad can mean you are not paid the annual uprating, can be relevant to decisions on deferring your retirement and can prevent you from de-retiring while abroad (see here).1
To be entitled to a category D retirement pension, you must have been:2
- resident in Great Britain for at least 10 years in any continuous period of 20 years ending on or after your 80th birthday; and
- ordinarily resident (see here) in Great Britain on:
- your 80th birthday; or
- the date on which you claimed the category D pension, if later.
EU co-ordination rules
If you are covered by any of the sets of European Union (EU) co-ordination rules (see here), you can:
- continue to receive an ‘old age’ pension from a member state covered by the set of co-ordination rules you are relying on, when you move to another member state (referred to as ‘exporting’ the pension - see here). It will be uprated as normal if the state that pays the pension continues to be the competent state to pay that benefit (see here);
- rely, if necessary, on insurance contributions paid in one or more of the member states to calculate your entitlement to UK retirement pensions and from the member state(s) covered by the set of co-ordination rules you are relying on; and
- rely, if necessary, on certain periods of residence in the member state(s) covered by the set of co-ordination rules you are relying on, to satisfy the residence requirement for a category D pension.
The last two bullet points above are each achieved under the aggregation principle (see here). You may receive pension payments from the UK and one or more member states, because your total award may be made in proportions that reflect the proportion of years of contributions paid, or periods of residence completed, in the UK and other member states, out of the total years of contributions paid or periods of residence completed in all member states.1
The requirement to be ordinarily resident in Great Britain for a category D retirement pension does not apply to you if, on the relevant date, you were ordinarily resident in a European Economic Area country and were covered by any of the Withdrawal Agreements or sets of co-ordination rules (see here).2
Although the main co-ordination rules were, in general, revoked in UK law from the end of 2020 and now only apply to those covered by the Withdrawal Agreement protections (see here), note the following.
- The provisions of the main co-ordination rules relating to the uprating of, and aggregation of insurance contributions for entitlement to, UK retirement pensions, were saved and continue to apply.3
- If you are not, or no longer, covered by the Withdrawal Agreement protections, but you are covered by the partial Withdrawal Agreement protections, the aggregation principle of the main co-ordination rules can apply (see here).4
- The UK–EU Protocol and UK–EFTA Convention contain rules on aggregation and uprating exported old age pensions. Although neither applies to Switzerland, the UK-Switzerland Convention covers retirement pensions5 (see here). Also, the main co-ordination rules may continue to apply due to the two bullet points above.
References
- 1
Arts 51, 52 and 58 EU Reg 883/04; for example, see Vol 2 paras 075771 and 076060-64 DMG; Arts 25 and 26 UK-IC; Arts SSC 45, 46 and 47 UK-EUP; Arts 49, 50, 51 UK-EFTAC
- 2
Reg 10(2) SS(WB&RP) Regs
- 3
Regs 5 and 9 SSC(RRDEL) Regs
- 4
Art 32 WA 2019; Art 31 UK-EFTA; Art 26a UK-SA; see also DWPWAG, Ch 1 paras 43-52; DMG Memo 11/22, paras 13-15; ADM Memo 15/22, paras 13-15
- 5
UK-SCC
Reciprocal and other international agreements
All the reciprocal agreements the UK has with other countries cover retirement benefits. These agreements can, for example, enable you to rely on periods of residence or insurance paid while living and working in that country to calculate your entitlement to UK retirement pensions.
Similarly, if you remain covered by an association agreement between the EU and another country, or by a replacement agreement, you may be able to do the same (see here).
For information on reciprocal agreements, see here. For a list of countries, see Appendix 5 and for specific information on retirement pensions, see here.
10. Social fund and other payments
Funeral payments
To qualify for a funeral expenses payment from the social fund, you must live in England or Wales.1
To qualify for a funeral support payment, you must be ordinarily resident (see here) in Scotland on the date you make your application.2
To qualify for either a funeral expenses payment or a funeral support payment:
- the person who has died must have been ordinarily resident in the UK at the date of their death (this does not apply to funeral support payment for stillborn babies);3 and
- the funeral must usually take place in the UK. However, for funeral support payment it can take place outside the UK if there are exceptional circumstances that merit the payment, or, for either payment, it can take place in a European Economic Area (EEA) country or the UK if you or your partner:4
- (funeral expenses payment only) have settled status granted under the European Union Settlement Scheme (EUSS), or are an EEA national with a right to reside as a worker (see here) or self-employed person (see here), including if you have retained either status (see here), or are a family member of such an EEA national (see here), or have a permanent right of residence acquired in less than five years (see here), or, arguably, are a person with any other free movement right of residence in the UK (see second bullet point in the note below); or
- (funeral support payment only) have pre-settled status or settled status granted under the EUSS, or a pending valid application for either, or had one of the residence rights in the above bullet point before the end of 2020, or came to the UK to join your (or their) family member who is an EEA national who began living in the UK before the end of 2020. Note: the policy intention is that the latter group applies during the first three months of residence in the UK.5
Note:
- Since the end of 2020, you can only have one of the free movement residence rights listed above if you are in a protected group (see here).
- Arguably, you can also qualify for a funeral expenses payment for a funeral held in an EEA state if you have any free movement right to reside in the UK. That is because the relevant law on residence rights has developed since the above rules were introduced and now covers additional groups of EEA nationals and their family members. The above rules were introduced following a Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) case which held that requiring a funeral to be in the UK was unlawfully discriminatory against European Union (EU) migrant workers.6 Arguably, the same applies to other groups who now have free movement residence rights but who are not listed in the funeral payment regulations – eg, people who have a permanent right of residence after five years of legal residence in the UK. For the continuing relevance of EU caselaw, see here.7
If you are responsible for the costs of a funeral of a child aged under 18 or a stillborn baby, you may be entitled to:
- a children’s funeral fund payment in England. The burial or cremation must take place in England, but there are no residence (or immigration status) requirements;8
- a child funeral fund payment in Wales. The child’s family home must be in Wales, but there are no other residence (or immigration status) requirements.9
References
- 1
Reg 7(9A) SFM&FE Regs
- 2
Reg 9(1) FEA(S) Regs
- 3
FEP Reg 7(5) SFM&FE Regs
FSP Reg 9(2)(a) and (6) FEA(S) Regs
- 4
FEP Reg 7(9) and (10) SFM&FE Regs
FSP Reg 9(2)(b) and (3)-(3B) FEA(S) Regs
- 5
p1 of Policy note to The Funeral Expense Assistance (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2024 No.363
- 6
O’Flynn v Adjudication Officer, C-237/94 [1996]; R(IS) 4/98
- 7
Art 24 EU Dir 2004/38
- 8
The Social Fund (Children’s Funeral Fund for England) Regulations 2019 No.1064; The Children’s Funeral Fund for England - technical guidance, Ministry of Justice, March 2020, paras 1.7 and 1.8
- 9
Winter fuel and heating payments
To qualify for a winter fuel payment from the social fund, you must be ordinarily resident (see here) in England or Wales on any day in the qualifying week.1
To qualify for a winter heating payment, you must be resident (see here) in Scotland on any day in the qualifying week.2
To qualify for a pension age winter heating payment, you must be ordinarily resident in Scotland on any day in the qualifying week.3
The qualifying week
The qualifying week for winter fuel payment and pension age winter heating payment is the week beginning on the third Monday in September. For winter heating payment, it is the week beginning on the first Monday in November before the winter you want to be paid for.
Note: it is arguable that, if you are covered by the main EU co-ordination rules, you can be entitled to a winter fuel payment or pension age winter heating payment if you are habitually resident in an EEA country (other than Cyprus, France, Greece, Malta, Portugal or Spain) and have a genuine and sufficient link to the UK (or Scotland) (see here). Despite these rules having been removed from the regulations, it is arguable that these benefits should continue to be classed as ‘old age benefits’ and therefore exportable. To make this argument, get advice and ask your adviser to contact CPAG.
To qualify for a cold weather payment, your home must be in England or Wales.4
To qualify for child winter heating payment, on any day in the qualifying week, you must be:5
- resident (see here) in Scotland; or
- habitually resident (see here) in an EEA state (other than Cyprus, France, Greece, Malta, Portugal or Spain) and have a genuine and sufficient link to Scotland (see here). If this applies, claim using a specific form.6
References
- 1
Reg 2 SFWFP Regs
- 2
Reg 4(2) WHA(LI)(S) Regs
- 3
Reg 8 The Winter Heating Assistance (Pension Age) (Scotland) Regulations 2024 No.351
- 4
Reg 1A(8) The Social Fund Cold Weather Payments (General) Regulations 1988 No.1724
- 5
Reg 4(1) and Sch WHACYP(S) Regs
- 6
mygov.scot/child-winter-heating-assistance-for-children-who-no-longer-live-in-scotland
Maternity grant payments
To qualify for a Sure Start maternity grant from the social fund, you must live in England or Wales.1
To qualify for a Best Start grant, you must be ordinarily resident in Scotland.2 In addition, if neither you nor your partner receives a qualifying means-tested benefit, but you qualify for a grant because you are aged under 20:3
Chapter 14: Going abroad
This chapter provides an overview of how your entitlement to benefits is affected if you, or your partner or child for whom you claim, go abroad. It explains how particular presence and residence conditions are affected by going abroad. The specific information about individual benefits is in Chapter 15.