The two-child limit: impact on abortion | CPAG

The two-child limit: impact on abortion

Published on: 
06 December 2020
Written by: 

Jonathan Bradshaw
Social Policy Research Unit
University of York

Although I have been a fierce critic of the two child-limit, it was mainly because of its certain impact on driving up child poverty. It has done that; estimates suggest that by the end of this Parliament, more than 600,000 families are likely to be subject to the limit, pushing an estimated 1.3 million children into, or deeper into, poverty. But many critics of the policy argued that it would increase abortions. I also made this argument but with some doubts because I did not think that women having a third conception would be aware of the policy. But it seems I may have been wrong.

There is now evidence from a British Pregnancy Advisory Service study that among women who were aware of the two-child limit and likely to be affected (women in receipt of universal credit or tax credits), 57 per cent said that the policy was important in their decision-making around whether or not to continue the pregnancy.

Further, the latest ONS abortion statistics have been published covering the period up to 2019. They contain three important findings that may be related to this issue.

  1. There was a sharp increase in abortion numbers after the two-child limit started (births after April 2017). See Figure 1. The rate of abortion per 1000 women in 2019 was the highest it has ever been. This is pre-COVID-19, 2019 fertility rates are at a nearly record low and so are conceptions, though we await ONS Conception data for 2019.
  2. Older women who are more likely to have had two children have had the sharpest increases in abortion. See Figure 2.
  3. Abortion rates are closely associated with deprivation. See Figure 3.

Unfortunately, ONS only publishes data for 0 and 1+ previous live births. But data shared with the Church of England shows that the number of abortions to women with 2+ previous lives births has risen most rapidly and especially after 2017 (see figure 4).1

Figure 1: Number of abortions in England and Wales, 2001-2019

Graph

Figure 2: Abortions in England and Wales per 1,000 women by maternal age 2009-2019

Graph

Figure 3: Abortions per 1,000 women in England by decile of the Index of Deprivation (1 most deprived 10 least deprived)

Graph

Figure 4: Number of abortions by number of previous live births in England and Wales

Graph

Conclusions

If these findings are related to the two-child policy, it is horrifying. China’s one-child policy was driven by burgeoning birth rates. We have sub-replacement fertility. There is no other country in history that has adapted social security policy to increase child poverty to reduce fertility or encourage abortion. It is a completely outrageous assault on liberty.

  • 1. Church of England used a Freedom of Information request to obtain a more detailed breakdown of the number of abortions by the number of previous pregnancies resulting in live or still birth.