Why March really was miserable for child poverty

Share

It’s been an awful month for UK child poverty but Iain Duncan Smith’s Centre for Social Justice (CSJ) has published some rather questionable claims made about the way we measure and use child poverty statistics.

CPAG analysis revealed that the cuts made to universal credit help for low income families will leave couples with children £960 a year worse, the Budget studiously avoided any mention of poverty and child poverty rose to 4 million, with new projections from the Institute for Fiscal Studies suggesting it is set to hit 5.1 million by 2022. Miserable March.

CSJ’s response was to attack the child poverty figures by saying ‘… while this is not fake news, it is misleading news”.

It says: “First, [they are] inaccurate. If the economy moves into recession, the measure says child poverty goes down”.

There are two very obvious reasons why this is plain wrong.

First, the child poverty figures are not one measure. They are a suite of four measures. Two of which - absolute poverty and material deprivation – capture significant falls in living standards for children in the poorest households.

Second, there is no iron law of nature that says, in a recession, relative child poverty - children living in households with incomes far below typical incomes - must always fall. Relative child poverty fell or did not rise in the economic downturn because governments (including the coalition, initially) acted to protect benefits at a time when median incomes were dropping.

It says: “Second, it focuses attention on the wrong things.” That it leads to politicians focusing their resources on moving people just below the poverty to over it and moving out of poverty doesn’t mean a life has been transformed.

The idea that previous governments ‘gamed’ the poverty target (as if such precision were possible) was comprehensively dismantled by the Institute for Fiscal Studies which said, in effect, that even with a considerably higher or lower poverty line, poverty fell between 1998 and 2010 as families across a wide income spectrum became better off. ‘Gaming’ did not happen. That IFS report is not new, yet this claim keeps being made without any evidence to back it up.

The progress made on child poverty before the economic downturn was actually down to the kind of broad approach - featuring improved parental employment and better childcare help, for example, as well as financial support for children - that CPAG and other charities insisted upon.

Does moving out of poverty change lives? The LSE’s Kerry Cooper and Kitty Stewart looked at 34 high quality studies which isolated the effect of income and concluded: “Low income affects direct measures of children’s well-being and development, including their cognitive ability, achievement and engagement in school, anxiety levels and behaviour. The evidence on cognitive development and school achievement was the clearest and most common, followed by that on social and behavioural development.”

You could say the CSJ’s line on the child poverty measures has ‘evolved’ over the years. In 2006, it published a report noting:

“Relative poverty rates, however, grew rapidly during the 1980s. The growth of child poverty on the relative measure was particularly alarming, with a rate of 12% in 1979 rising to 27% by 1992. Whether one wants to call it poverty or not, this huge increase in income inequality has been rightly described as “one of the biggest social changes in Britain since the Second World War.” [Emphasis added]

A decade ago the significance of children growing up in low income families was understood right across the political spectrum.

What’s changed?


Related Publication

OUT NOW - NEW Welfare Benefits and Tax Credits Handbook 2017/18Welfare Rights Conference 2017

Known as the 'adviser's bible' CPAG’s Welfare Benefits and Tax Credits Handbook is the essential and best-selling guide to all benefits and tax credits.

Our definitive guide to all benefits and tax credits is an essential resource for all professional advisers serious about giving the best and most accurate advice to their clients. 

With detailed information on all the recent changes to the social security system, including the latest on the roll-out of universal credit, the right to reside test and the sanctions regime, the Welfare Benefits and Tax Credits Handbook provides comprehensive advice about entitlement in 2017/18.

Order your copy online

Welfare Rights Conference 2017

Universal Credit – Understanding and Managing the Risks for Families Welfare Rights Conference 2017

Manchester Thursday 7 September 2017
London Thursday 14 September 2017

This year's conference focuses on the very real risks facing families as the roll out of Universal Credit continues.

Click here to book your place and for more information


Some of our Training courses

Using legislation and caselaw
Friday 14 July 2017, 10:00-16:30, London
£138 voluntary organisations, £195 statutory/other organisations,
CPD hours: 5
More information - Book now

Challenging PIP decisions
Thursday 20 July 2017, 10:00-16:30, London
£138 voluntary organisations, £195 statutory/other organisations,
CPD hours: 5
More information - Book now

Benefits for non-benefit advisers
Monday 24 July and Tuesday 25 July 2017, 10:00-16:30, London
£220 voluntary organisations, £315 statutory/other organisations,
CPD hours: 5
More information - Book now

Universal credit
Thursday 27 July 2017, 10:00-16:30, London
£138 voluntary organisations, £195 statutory/other organisations,
CPD hours: 5
More information - Book now

View all our Training courses