How many children will Universal Credit lift out of poverty?

Share

Just days after Iain Duncan Smith resigned as Work & Pensions Secretary, citing his unease with the Summer Budget’s cuts to Universal Credit, today the Government has published a written answer in which it refuses to update its own assessment of how many children, if any, will be lifted out of poverty by the flagship policy following these cuts.

The Summer Budget last year slashed or eliminated altogether work allowances for low-paid workers – the work allowance sets out how much people can earn before their UC entitlements start being reduced at a rate of 65p per £1 earned.

This was surprising to many observers. This work allowance is one the key planks of Universal Credit. Undermining the work allowance, undermines a key aspect of Universal Credit, which incentivises moves into work by allowing people to keep more of their benefits as they increase their hours.

In 2011, the government said Universal Credit would lift over 350,000 children out of poverty - even more, it claimed, when you factor in the dynamic impacts on employment and earnings of the new benefit:

Universal Credit will have a substantial impact on poverty in the steady-state. As outlined in paragraph 22, the Department estimates the combined impact of take-up and higher entitlement might lift around 950,000 individuals out of poverty, including over 350,000 children and more than 600,000 working-age adults. 

In 2013, the Government downgraded this figure to 150,000 children (in a memorably opaque written answer):

However, before taking account of any expected behavioural change among the self-employed affected, modelling estimates that universal credit reduces the number of individuals in relative income poverty by some 400,000; including more than 150,000 children and around 250,000 adults.

Then today, the Government point-blank refused to answer the question:

We know that work is the best route out of poverty, and Universal Credit is designed to strengthen incentives for parents to move into and progress in work. Ignoring the impact that Universal Credit has on incentivising work and raising the incomes of families is inappropriate.

In refusing to respond to the question asked by Stephen Timms MP, the minister is ignoring one set of effects of Universal Credit - which previously it had been willing to produce assessments on - by saying any assessment of Universal Credit must not ignore other effects. The inference is that they know the answer and it isn’t pretty.

There is no doubt that Universal Credit’s poverty-fighting capability has been degraded in recent years. What’s just as worrying is that ministers aren’t willing to look at the likely impacts of a programme costing billions of pounds and affecting millions of families. 


Related Publication

OUT NOW - NEW Welfare Benefits and Tax Credits Handbook 2017/18Welfare Benefits & Tax Credits Handbook 2017-2018

Known as the 'adviser's bible' CPAG’s Welfare Benefits and Tax Credits Handbook is the essential and best-selling guide to all benefits and tax credits.

Our definitive guide to all benefits and tax credits is an essential resource for all professional advisers serious about giving the best and most accurate advice to their clients. 

With detailed information on all the recent changes to the social security system, including the latest on the roll-out of universal credit, the right to reside test and the sanctions regime, the Welfare Benefits and Tax Credits Handbook provides comprehensive advice about entitlement in 2017/18.

Order your copy online

Upcoming events for 2017

Two Child Limit – Implementation, Challenges and the Policy Context Two Child Limit – Implementation, Challenges and the Policy Context

London Thursday 22 June 2017 

This seminar will examine the two child limit in tax credits and means-tested benefits and its inevitable impact on child poverty.

Click here to book your place and for more information


Welfare Rights Conference 2017Welfare Rights Conference 2017

Universal Credit – Understanding and Managing the Risks for Families 

Manchester Thursday 7 September 2017
London Thursday 14 September 2017

This year's conference focuses on the very real risks facing families as the roll out of Universal Credit continues.

Click here to book your place and for more information


Some of our Training courses

Benefits for students
Thursday 8 June 2017, 10:00-16:30, London
£138 voluntary organisations, £195 statutory/other organisations, CPD hours: 5
More information - Book now

Challenging ESA Decisions
Friday 9 June 2017, 10:00-16:30, London
£138 voluntary organisations, £195 statutory/other organisations, CPD hours: 5
More information - Book now

Universal credit
Tuesday 13 June 2017, 10:00-16:30, Manchester
£138 voluntary organisations, £195 statutory/other organisations, CPD hours: 5
More information - Book now

View all our Training courses